METAPHYSICS IS GAY V. TED CRUZ SATURDAY SMACKDOWN
| Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | well-lubricated obsidian antidepressant drug | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | comical sick personal credit line | 02/22/14 | | well-lubricated obsidian antidepressant drug | 02/22/14 | | Mentally impaired field alpha | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/23/14 | | Walnut curious generalized bond stead | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | learning disabled gunner ticket booth | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | bistre odious hell | 02/23/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | Avocado Rehab Mad-dog Skullcap | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/23/14 | | bistre odious hell | 02/23/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/23/14 | | bistre odious hell | 02/23/14 | | bistre odious hell | 02/23/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/23/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | elite mewling mental disorder | 02/22/14 | | medicated boltzmann | 02/22/14 | | pink passionate tattoo prole | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Bisexual theatre | 02/22/14 | | well-lubricated obsidian antidepressant drug | 02/22/14 | | Mentally impaired field alpha | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | elite mewling mental disorder | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | well-lubricated obsidian antidepressant drug | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Mentally impaired field alpha | 02/22/14 | | Avocado Rehab Mad-dog Skullcap | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | cocky genital piercing | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | Floppy Yellow Institution Mediation | 02/22/14 | | elite mewling mental disorder | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | chocolate chad | 02/22/14 | | Floppy Yellow Institution Mediation | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Mentally impaired field alpha | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | well-lubricated obsidian antidepressant drug | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Floppy Yellow Institution Mediation | 02/22/14 | | well-lubricated obsidian antidepressant drug | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | well-lubricated obsidian antidepressant drug | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | well-lubricated obsidian antidepressant drug | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | Mentally impaired field alpha | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | medicated boltzmann | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | medicated boltzmann | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Unhinged ladyboy step-uncle's house | 02/22/14 | | mahogany duck-like sandwich | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | cocky genital piercing | 02/22/14 | | Khaki greedy university | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | mahogany duck-like sandwich | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | arrogant lascivious brunch fortuitous meteor | 02/22/14 | | claret place of business | 02/22/14 | | arrogant lascivious brunch fortuitous meteor | 02/22/14 | | Mentally impaired field alpha | 02/22/14 | | elite mewling mental disorder | 02/22/14 | | well-lubricated obsidian antidepressant drug | 02/22/14 | | elite mewling mental disorder | 02/22/14 | | pink passionate tattoo prole | 02/22/14 | | Mentally impaired field alpha | 02/22/14 | | purple trip sneaky criminal | 02/22/14 | | elite mewling mental disorder | 02/22/14 | | Mentally impaired field alpha | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | olive persian range | 02/22/14 | | Mentally impaired field alpha | 02/22/14 | | boyish state hominid | 02/22/14 | | pink passionate tattoo prole | 02/22/14 | | claret place of business | 02/22/14 | | geriatric depressive | 02/22/14 | | claret place of business | 02/23/14 | | Consuela | 07/13/26 | | erotic razzmatazz base | 02/22/14 | | arrogant lascivious brunch fortuitous meteor | 02/23/14 | | Aggressive theater stage elastic band | 02/23/14 | | ww2 was an inverted butlerian jihad | 07/13/26 |
Poast new message in this thread
 |
Date: February 22nd, 2014 2:13 PM Author: Khaki greedy university
I like this. Here are some initial thoughts.
I am a bit troubled by what seems to me to be a conflation between the basic posture of scientific realism--which, in your parlance, admitted at one point of the existence of protons simpliciter--and what you read as Dewey's reconciliation of scientific progress with scientific realism. You mention at the outset that we can still be realists about unobserved scientific phenomena should we adopt Dewey's position, but Dewey's position, as I'm reading it, seems best characterized as a way of denying that the debate really exists, or otherwise as merely denying realism.
After all, says Dewey, all we need is to introduce the concept of an instrumentality, and both realism and the principal objection to realism--that realism posits really-existing objects that account for scientific phenomena--can be saved. And yet it seems to me that, in order for us to 'save' realism, Dewey's instrumentality must, at a minimum, retain the very feature of realism that subjects it to irrealist critique in the first instance.
So many questions will be along the line of: isn't Dewey's defintion of an instrumentality just a vacuity? If we define the instrumentality as just that scientific object that, if it existed, would explain all of our scientific observations relevant to that instrumentality, how is this not fundamentally a concession to the irrealist? It seems to me that Dewey's concept of a scientific instrumentality has no more content than 'wherever you go, there you are'; in other words, Dewey's position seems tacitly irrealist.
So my questions are going to be along the lines of: don't scientific realists claim the existence of protons simpliciter, with the caveat that, hey, we might be wrong? If they do, isn't Dewey's solution to the caveat just a way of conceding that the objects of science are irreal, if we define them as just those real things that: (1) do not exist simpliciter; and (2) explain phenomena but not really anything else? That seems to be to be almost textbook irrealism. So I'll want you to tell me: if I'm an irrealist, why can't I claim Dewey as being in my camp?
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2500975&forum_id=2],#25065924) |
 |
Date: February 22nd, 2014 2:25 PM Author: Khaki greedy university
yup, that's been my experience too. like, i wrote a paper kind of like this (it was better of course :]) about how the dominant and inclusive readings of aristotle's theoria can be reconciled through like some weird kind of supervenience relationship. it was textbook undergrad, a bit too clever by half. my professor sat me down and was like, this is a clever paper and i'm giving you an A for the course, but did you ever stop to consider that even if it is possible that aristotle could both have meant that theoria is a good life and theoria is contemplation of god, and you could marshal textual support for that, that there is any reason on earth to think that aristotle himself might have some kind of proto-jaegwon kim emergence relationship in mind, some several thousand years before its first introduction in the literature? do you really think he was that good, or are you just retarded?
that like, 10 minute conversation alone gave me an entirely new way of approaching my classes from then on. basically, the key to success in philosophy is to approach problems from a position of radical modesty, or otherwise to be smarter than everyone else. interestingly, those who should be in the first camp (me) often start out thinking they're in the second, and the few who should be in the second almost always think they should be in the first. russell's letter to frege was a cute exception to that, though
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2500975&forum_id=2],#25065988) |
Date: February 22nd, 2014 1:33 PM Author: olive persian range
my thing today fell through so no worries.
my suggestion is the following: the five judges, individually, offer a cursory rating in this thread with a few comments. later on, in tinychat, when the papers are presented, we ask questions emerging from these comments. this'll give the writers a little time to prepare and make it a little more of a dialogue. afterwards, the judges can confer and offer a collective rating of the paper and the presentation/response.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2500975&forum_id=2],#25065726) |
 |
Date: February 22nd, 2014 2:17 PM Author: olive persian range
preliminary rating for metaphysics is gay: 168
This paper is well-written, strong scholarship, and teaches me a lot about Dewey's views on the philosophy of science, a topic with which I am not very acquainted. However, I wonder if it is a little too uncritical with Dewey, or, put another way, whether it fails to vindicate Dewey's view vis-a-vis the current debates within which it situates that view.
MIGtp makes - among others - the following statements:
1. Dewey believes in the objects of particle physics (here I take "believes in" to mean "posits as part of an ontological scheme") *insofar as* they produce certain behavior, and not as natural kinds.
2. Anti-realism is the view that empirical adequacy does not imply some deep truth about the joint-carving capacities of our theories.
It is difficult for me to see how these two in tandem do not make Dewey an anti-realist.
Now MIGtp attempts to evade this criticism of Dewey by suggesting that Dewey's mid-tier "hypothetical objects" have some roughness to them which a final, completed science might not. Or maybe there is no final, completed science; in which case they just lack something natural kinds have. But why posit these hypothetical objects at all? What purpose do they serve? Moreover, why should explanatory adequacy suffice as a measure of their existence, if not for the existence of other, more real(?) objects? It seems to me Dewey, under this presentation, might be giving us not the best of both worlds but the worst of both: the anti-realist's dissatisfaction with explanatory adequacy as a measure of deep ontology and of the world's structure, and the realist's ontological promiscuity.
In responding to this criticism I urge MIGtp not to accidentally beg the question against either party in the current debate. For example, the paper's penultimate sentence reads ". . . our set of natural kinds." The realist, of course, does not merely think that there is some subjective, human-determined view of natural kinds, but that there are some objectively real ones out there.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2500975&forum_id=2],#25065944) |
 |
Date: February 22nd, 2014 10:06 PM Author: Avocado Rehab Mad-dog Skullcap
ljl
"More importantly, that an atom can be better understood today as a nucleus with orbiting electrons, rather than as the earlier plumb pudding model, is not grounds for dismissing the existence of the atom as that referent accountable for certain molecular properties "
the secret language is: "i'm full of shit and just filling the space on the page".
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2500975&forum_id=2],#25068454) |
Date: February 22nd, 2014 3:20 PM Author: cocky genital piercing
i lost the competition because i didn't finish it before the deadline.
congrats mig - nice essay btw.
however, i will be poasting my finished product later tonight. if you don't want to read it fine. but i will still poast it. i think mig deserves at least one product to compete with since he put all this work into writing.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2500975&forum_id=2],#25066240)
|
 |
Date: February 22nd, 2014 10:20 PM Author: boyish state hominid
Jesus the more I think about this the more brutal it is. Ted Cruz spent a month hyping this contest. Metaphysics was like I'm done when do you want to post? His article is clear and at least decent.
Then Ted Cruz posts two paragraphs describing the content of an essay he will never write.
Just the most devastating self-pwn of all time.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2500975&forum_id=2],#25068509) |
|
|