Explain to me again why a "Flat Tax" is unfair? Thank
| Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/17/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/19/17 | | Rambunctious Beady-eyed French Chef Headpube | 11/19/17 | | Violet arousing space | 11/19/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | Glittery Sticky Generalized Bond | 11/21/17 | | Slate sickened gas station | 11/21/17 | | overrated sapphire address patrolman | 11/21/17 | | Pink Principal's Office | 11/21/17 | | lime gaping | 11/21/17 | | Abnormal dead stain church | 11/21/17 | | salmon cerebral rigor organic girlfriend | 11/21/17 | | Dashing becky cruise ship | 11/19/17 | | Maize magical national | 11/21/17 | | fragrant brilliant idiot | 11/21/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | Maize magical national | 11/21/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | Maize magical national | 11/21/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | Copper Mischievous Range | 11/21/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | fragrant brilliant idiot | 11/21/17 | | Maize magical national | 11/21/17 | | fragrant brilliant idiot | 11/21/17 | | Vengeful stimulating newt | 11/21/17 | | awkward lay famous landscape painting | 11/21/17 | | lascivious partner | 11/21/17 | | fragrant brilliant idiot | 11/21/17 | | awkward lay famous landscape painting | 11/21/17 | | chest-beating nubile point | 11/21/17 | | Claret Masturbator Mental Disorder | 11/21/17 | | dull stage | 11/21/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | Electric Resort | 11/21/17 | | Mind-boggling hissy fit | 11/21/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | Dashing becky cruise ship | 11/21/17 | | adventurous wine deer antler really tough guy | 11/21/17 | | Odious travel guidebook | 11/21/17 | | razzmatazz elastic band area | 11/21/17 | | Odious travel guidebook | 11/21/17 | | Mind-boggling hissy fit | 11/21/17 | | razzmatazz elastic band area | 11/21/17 | | out-of-control legend new version | 11/21/17 | | Violent Opaque Dog Poop | 11/21/17 | | Misanthropic stead preventive strike | 11/21/17 | | out-of-control legend new version | 11/21/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | Misanthropic stead preventive strike | 11/21/17 | | out-of-control legend new version | 11/21/17 | | fragrant brilliant idiot | 11/21/17 | | out-of-control legend new version | 11/21/17 | | insecure swashbuckling orchestra pit | 11/21/17 | | fragrant brilliant idiot | 11/21/17 | | vibrant school | 11/21/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | Odious travel guidebook | 11/21/17 | | insecure swashbuckling orchestra pit | 11/21/17 | | Odious travel guidebook | 11/21/17 | | Mind-boggling hissy fit | 11/21/17 | | Odious travel guidebook | 11/21/17 | | Mind-boggling hissy fit | 11/21/17 | | Odious travel guidebook | 11/21/17 | | fragrant brilliant idiot | 11/21/17 | | Odious travel guidebook | 11/21/17 | | henna deranged roommate | 11/21/17 | | Mind-boggling hissy fit | 11/21/17 | | henna deranged roommate | 11/21/17 | | Dashing becky cruise ship | 11/21/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | Dashing becky cruise ship | 11/21/17 | | Misanthropic stead preventive strike | 11/21/17 | | insecure swashbuckling orchestra pit | 11/21/17 | | Mind-boggling hissy fit | 11/21/17 | | fragrant brilliant idiot | 11/21/17 | | vigorous coldplay fan milk | 11/21/17 | | Coiffed Digit Ratio | 11/21/17 | | razzmatazz elastic band area | 11/21/17 | | vibrant school | 11/21/17 | | histrionic balding black woman ratface | 11/21/17 | | Dashing becky cruise ship | 11/21/17 | | talented chad factory reset button | 11/21/17 | | fragrant brilliant idiot | 11/21/17 | | out-of-control legend new version | 11/21/17 | | vibrant school | 11/21/17 |
Poast new message in this thread
|
Date: November 21st, 2017 3:12 PM Author: Maize magical national
I provided a standard shitlib response for entertainment purposes only.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Hall-Rabushka tax would be highly regressive, in part because high-income households tend to consume less of their income than lower-income households and because investment income would not be taxed (or rather double-taxed).
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3800962&forum_id=2#34741089)
|
|
Date: November 21st, 2017 3:21 PM Author: fragrant brilliant idiot
fair enough on your first point
but why bring up a consumption tax when we are talking about income tax? and just because 'tend' exists, a flat tax on consumption is still a flat tax.
investment income should be taxed as income. it is income. that aspect of hall rabushka is fairly considered regressive because it treats different types of income differently, by definition, to the wealthier peoples' benefits
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3800962&forum_id=2#34741173)
|
|
Date: November 21st, 2017 9:50 PM Author: Mind-boggling hissy fit
I'm not taking it that far. It is entirely plausible, for example if taking $200 from a poor just means they can't afford oxy for the next little while vs. taking $200 from a UMC means he isn't gonna enroll his kids in soccer camp.
Let me be clear, I can also formulate many examples going the other way. I just don't like utility arguments like that because unless we are talking about the taking away of basic necessities (we are not) then its a stupid way to approach things.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3800962&forum_id=2#34744697) |
Date: November 21st, 2017 9:04 PM Author: out-of-control legend new version
IF you believe in an income tax, THEN that tax should tax labor.
Gains in earnings for high income individual generally does not come from labor. Too often, these individuals gain income from capital, not labor.
Special interests will never let this happen, but tcr tax plan would be 0% up to $150k, ~20% up to 500k, and ~70% thereafter. This stat doesn't get pushed hard enough, but we could have 95% of this country pay jack shit and just tax the fuck out of the super rich. The idea that $60k earners should spend a week doing taxes to write an $8k check is absurd.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3800962&forum_id=2#34744403) |
|
Date: November 21st, 2017 9:33 PM Author: out-of-control legend new version
Yeah, that's absurd. Not even worth the time to fill out the form, have the government look things over, and deal with collections of back taxes.
And just LOL at the logic that not having skin in the game, or the threat of a higher rate, stopping someone from earning more. 10 out of 10 people will choose to earn more and pay more under ANY tax code.
I'm a huge Trumpmo and the plan in my OP is tcr populist solution.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3800962&forum_id=2#34744569) |
Date: November 21st, 2017 9:07 PM Author: insecure swashbuckling orchestra pit
its not unfair but impractical
there is no good flat tax rate to use unless you are willing to either destroy the federal govt or the poor/lower middle class people
set it too low to not affect the poor/lower middle class and you wont raise enough revenue. set it too high and you are going to make life miserable for people making < 60K or so
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3800962&forum_id=2#34744428) |
Date: November 21st, 2017 9:20 PM Author: vigorous coldplay fan milk
Chris Rock summed it up best talking about alimony
"if you make 30 million and the bitch want 15, that's fine you ain't starvin. but if you make 30 thousand and the bitch want half, you just might have to kill her!"
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3800962&forum_id=2#34744487) |
Date: November 21st, 2017 10:03 PM Author: out-of-control legend new version
*gets paid 80k in stock options*
One weird trick hehe
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3800962&forum_id=2#34744797) |
|
|