Why does self-proclaimed non-Jew RSFs family belong to a NJ synagogue?
| Unholy canary kitchen | 02/04/18 | | jade point | 02/04/18 | | Dashing gas station | 02/04/18 | | Unholy canary kitchen | 02/04/18 | | big cuck market | 02/04/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/04/18 | | charismatic gay regret sex offender | 02/04/18 | | gold cuckold space | 02/04/18 | | charismatic gay regret sex offender | 02/04/18 | | Passionate National | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/04/18 | | Cowardly box office | 02/04/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | Erotic Shivering School Cafeteria | 02/05/18 | | harsh bonkers double fault | 02/14/18 | | big cuck market | 02/04/18 | | cheese-eating sneaky criminal fanboi | 02/04/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/04/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | Passionate National | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | lilac library brethren | 02/05/18 | | Passionate National | 02/05/18 | | lilac library brethren | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | saffron sanctuary | 02/04/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/04/18 | | saffron sanctuary | 02/04/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Cowardly box office | 02/04/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | excitant locale | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | Passionate National | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | Unholy canary kitchen | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | lilac library brethren | 02/05/18 | | comical kitty cat | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | comical kitty cat | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | comical kitty cat | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | lilac library brethren | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | lilac library brethren | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | lilac library brethren | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | lilac library brethren | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | boyish jet-lagged home | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | excitant locale | 02/05/18 | | Well-lubricated station | 02/05/18 | | Soul-stirring Incel | 02/14/18 | | irradiated stain set | 02/14/18 | | aggressive balding ticket booth newt | 02/05/18 | | Erotic Shivering School Cafeteria | 02/05/18 | | rusted stage kitty | 02/05/18 | | jade point | 02/05/18 | | Shimmering heady university really tough guy | 02/05/18 | | Emerald Pocket Flask | 02/05/18 | | Unholy canary kitchen | 02/07/18 |
Poast new message in this thread
Date: February 4th, 2018 1:29 PM Author: jade point
dude stop writing lies about him. we don't need to stoop to that level.
have even seen him write the ((())) nazi stuff on here and his buddy "lt dan" asks about the "jewish question" all the time.
no way in hell this guy is a Jew. they're funny. RSF isn't.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35320771) |
Date: February 4th, 2018 1:35 PM Author: cheese-eating sneaky criminal fanboi
sort of reminds me of Mark Cuban. the big fat Jew sort of a breed apart from the nebbish waif Woody Allen type.
I remember some dick professor was name dropping that fucker to me during office hours. at that time he was dancing with the stars. fuck if I had a billion dollars I would not be dancing for other people's amusement, people would be dancing for mine.
both are big fat rich guys with something to prove
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35320809) |
Date: February 4th, 2018 1:41 PM Author: saffron sanctuary
tbf its a reform synagogue with a woman "rabbi"
who in they're right mind would affirm being affiliated with that
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35320854) |
|
Date: February 5th, 2018 4:42 PM Author: Wine Overrated Love Of Her Life
Regarding #2
"If he was super Catholic then why on earth didn't he get your mom to convert???"
Hi is not "super catholic." He was raised catholic, and these days is basically agnostic. Neither parent practices any religion.
"I would never be cool raising my kid Jewish and I'm freakin' part Jewish. Please explain."
Cannot explain, as I was not raised Jewish. The only "religious schooling" I ever had was going to an Episcopalian affiliated school in MFH when I was much younger.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35331525) |
|
Date: February 5th, 2018 12:09 PM Author: Well-lubricated station
Fair. But in response:
1) I don't belong to any synagogue and never have;
2) I actually have attended Churches much of my life and have been baptized; and
3) I still admit to being part Jewish.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35329026) |
|
Date: February 5th, 2018 2:40 PM Author: irradiated stain set
ok man. ashkenazi jews comprise like 90% of the world's jewry. to say that the jewish people in general are ethnically diverse isn't really accurate.
I used hook nose as an example of a typical jewish trait. yes, some jews don't have a hook nose and yes, some non-jews have hook noses. Clearly jews descended from people who at one point were not jews, so any physical traits common to jews will surely show up in other ethnic groups. And yes, you are right that jews have intermarried though historically much less so than today.
What are we debating again? Is it your position that jews do not comprise a distinct ethnic group?
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35330311) |
|
Date: February 5th, 2018 2:51 PM Author: Well-lubricated station
My argument is that Jews, non-surprisingly, look like whatever countries they are from. Ethiopian Jews are black, Euro Jews look European, Indian Jews look Indian, and Middle Eastern Jews look Middle Eastern. As to Ashkenazi Jews: https://www.livescience.com/40247-ashkenazi-jews-have-european-genes.html
As to numbers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashkenazi_Jews ( Sergio DellaPergola in a rough calculation of Sephardic and Mizrahi Jews, implies that Ashkenazi Jews make up less than 74% of Jews worldwide.[33] Other estimates place Ashkenazi Jews as making up about 75% of Jews worldwide).
Having 25% or so non-Euro (what most would consider white) seems pretty diverse to me. That's probably more diverse than the Mormons, for example.
Re: intermarriage - apparently, that has ebbed and flowed throughout history. There were times it was extremely rare, and times when it was extremely common. For example, it was extremely common during the Roman era.
I think Jews are a community and a religion.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35330438) |
|
Date: February 5th, 2018 3:04 PM Author: irradiated stain set
I'd disagree with the argument in your first sentence at least re: ashkenazim. "Russian" jews (i.e. jews from the pale of settlement) do not resemble slavs. They resemble ashkenazim from other european countries like Germany and Hungary (who look nothing like ethnic Germans and Hungarians) because they are all part of the same ethnic group and lived for generations in insular communities like shtetls.
For example, I know exactly in Ukraine where most of my ancestors emigrated from. No one has ever mistaken me for a Ukrainian or other slav.
As to your last point, I would agree if we could also agree that ashkenazim (who make up the vast majority of the world's jewish population) are a distinct ethnic group.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35330564)
|
|
Date: February 5th, 2018 3:48 PM Author: Well-lubricated station
This all gets complicated as well. I know a bunch of people that are heavily mixed. For my wife, one grandma is from some super religious Jewish family, the other is from Ukrainian landed gentry. I have a friend that calls himself Jewish but it all comes from one Jewish grandma and he looks like your typical Russian. Indeed, among famous Russians you see the same thing. Lenin was part. Visotsky was part. Even good ol' Zhirinovsky is part.
The "purest" Jews that lived in shtetls and didn't integrate died in huge numbers during WW2. If you look at where the shtetls were and what the Nazis grabbed first, you'll notice complete overlap. After Communism, the Jewish community got split up and intermarriage was massive (actually, it was significant even during Catherine the Great, who took significant steps to "strongly encourage" the Jews to integrate). I agree that many Russian Jews can trace genetics to other Central European places, but so can many Russians that were merchants (including in my family, we had people that intermarried into Italian and Greek families, as well as German and Baltic states). The point is that heavily mixed peoples make bad candidates for labels as ethnicities. By the way, a lot of Slavs are mixed too. Take a trip to Odessa or Crimea and look around and notice the massive amount of Turkish blood in people who will identify as Slavs.
What I can say is that I was reading that the Haredi Jews in particular are solid candidates to be defined as an ethnicity. They have had exceedingly little intermarriage, and a well-defined uniform culture and language.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35331046) |
|
Date: February 5th, 2018 4:07 PM Author: irradiated stain set
"The "purest" Jews that lived in shtetls and didn't integrate died in huge numbers during WW2."
To the extent you are citing this to suggest that the population of Jews I am referring to was wiped out in the holocaust, I think your argument ignores the mass migration of Russian Jews to the United States from late 19th - Early 20th century. Intermarriage of these once pure people is rampant, and I think you are right that in a generation or 2 it will be so watered down that the only distinct ethnic jews are the Haredi which is a terrifying thought.
I am not suggesting that the migration of jews suggests they were heavily mixed. The opposite actually. They migrated but didn't intermarry hence a hungarian jew is genetically similar to a belorusian jew. If some of your ancestors were nomadic and made love with the locals along the way, I don't think that is relevant to my argument.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35331227) |
|
Date: February 5th, 2018 4:24 PM Author: Well-lubricated station
"To the extent you are citing this to suggest that the population of Jews I am referring to was wiped out in the holocaust, I think your argument ignores the mass migration of Russian Jews to the United States from late 19th - Early 20th century"
I thought you were talking about Russian Jews that lived through the Soviet era? If not then fair enough but even there, as you note, you have the intermarriage issue with the exception of a few ultra-ortho communities.
"I think you are right that in a generation or 2 it will be so watered down that the only distinct ethnic jews are the Haredi which is a terrifying thought"
Not sure why this is so terrifying. I notice some Jews are super invested in this and I have no idea why. Look at those people. Objectively, they're actually the worst group in the Jewish community. Why would you want to be more like them?
"I am not suggesting that the migration of jews suggests they were heavily mixed. The opposite actually. They migrated but didn't intermarry hence a hungarian jew is genetically similar to a belorusian jew."
Except, they did intermarry at various points unless they were shtetl Jews. Because ultimately, Euro society was class and profession-based and marriage and if you were middle or upper-class merchants, for example, then you were going to marry within that class. Same reason Donald Trump's kids married a bunch of Jews.
The other thing is look at the live science article I linked you above. The actual genetic studies show there was a huge amount of intermarriage, including into the Jewish community (especially men marrying women). I suspect when Jewish women married out they tended to convert to the husband's religion (so their offspring wouldn't be identified as a Jew to be studied), btw, so that's my theory for why it seems to be uneven.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35331360) |
|
Date: February 5th, 2018 4:33 PM Author: irradiated stain set
"Not sure why this is so terrifying. I notice some Jews are super invested in this and I have no idea why. Look at those people. Objectively, they're actually the worst group in the Jewish community. Why would you want to be more like them?"
It's terrifying for me specifically because they are the worst group, and I've noticed with the springing up of large communities of these people in towns like Lakewood, NJ, a lot of people associate all Jews with Haredi, who are only ever in the news for being criminals. I've had uncomfortable conversations with goyim who clearly and justifiably have negative feelings toward haredi and tried to explain that they aren't representative of all jews.
Interesting conversation. Thanks for your perspective.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35331431) |
Date: February 5th, 2018 11:01 AM Author: rusted stage kitty
On XO you can be anything you want. For example, the poster idris elba pretends to be black. RSF can be whatever teh fuck he invents as a schtick and he never has to drop character and "confess" to some IRL shit. Nor is running a schtick a denunciation of his people.
XO is a wonderful oasis and use it for its worth and never, ever mistake it for IRL
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=3882048&forum_id=2#35328532) |
|
|