The history of Byzantium is sad. Just slow, painful retreat into Constantinople
| Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 09/24/18 | | vigorous offensive genital piercing potus | 09/24/18 | | Impertinent peach national security agency theatre | 09/24/18 | | Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 09/24/18 | | Milky doctorate associate | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | Floppy french parlor | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | brindle site boiling water | 09/25/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | Maize wonderful round eye pit | 04/22/23 | | fragrant market | 09/24/18 | | Impertinent peach national security agency theatre | 09/24/18 | | Violent demanding location | 09/24/18 | | Idiotic Juggernaut Casino | 09/24/18 | | Diverse Nubile School Cafeteria Candlestick Maker | 04/22/23 | | Transparent Piazza | 04/22/23 | | Impertinent peach national security agency theatre | 09/24/18 | | Milky doctorate associate | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | Milky doctorate associate | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | Sticky Thriller Quadroon | 09/24/18 | | Idiotic Juggernaut Casino | 09/24/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | high-end native | 09/30/18 | | Diverse Nubile School Cafeteria Candlestick Maker | 04/22/23 | | vigorous offensive genital piercing potus | 09/24/18 | | Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 09/24/18 | | Impertinent peach national security agency theatre | 09/24/18 | | Milky doctorate associate | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | Milky doctorate associate | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | Milky doctorate associate | 09/24/18 | | Fiercely-loyal confused national | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | angry fantasy-prone lay | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | Outnumbered light new version abode | 09/25/18 | | high-end native | 09/26/18 | | Outnumbered light new version abode | 09/27/18 | | high-end native | 09/27/18 | | Outnumbered light new version abode | 09/30/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | Outnumbered light new version abode | 09/30/18 | | high-end native | 10/21/19 | | naked hunting ground stage | 01/30/20 | | Maize wonderful round eye pit | 04/22/23 | | Maize wonderful round eye pit | 04/22/23 | | Maize wonderful round eye pit | 04/22/23 | | angry fantasy-prone lay | 10/01/18 | | high-end native | 12/10/18 | | canary balding fortuitous meteor | 01/29/20 | | Maize wonderful round eye pit | 04/22/23 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | ultramarine learning disabled state | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | Electric Corner Stain | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | Impertinent peach national security agency theatre | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | angry fantasy-prone lay | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | angry fantasy-prone lay | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/25/18 | | angry fantasy-prone lay | 09/25/18 | | high-end native | 09/25/18 | | angry fantasy-prone lay | 09/25/18 | | high-end native | 09/25/18 | | razzle-dazzle field | 09/24/18 | | Histrionic Clear Public Bath Police Squad | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | ultramarine learning disabled state | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | Fiercely-loyal confused national | 09/24/18 | | razzle address hissy fit | 09/24/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | Mildly autistic orchestra pit | 09/24/18 | | yellow bawdyhouse fat ankles | 09/24/18 | | Violent demanding location | 09/24/18 | | yellow bawdyhouse fat ankles | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | yellow bawdyhouse fat ankles | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | spruce stead | 04/22/23 | | translucent gaming laptop | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/24/18 | | translucent gaming laptop | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/25/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | Diverse Nubile School Cafeteria Candlestick Maker | 04/22/23 | | swollen titillating reading party | 09/24/18 | | high-end native | 09/25/18 | | translucent gaming laptop | 09/24/18 | | yellow bawdyhouse fat ankles | 09/24/18 | | Mildly autistic orchestra pit | 09/24/18 | | vigorous offensive genital piercing potus | 09/25/18 | | high-end native | 10/21/19 | | sick indirect expression immigrant | 09/24/18 | | beta nowag ceo | 09/24/18 | | Violent demanding location | 09/25/18 | | Impertinent peach national security agency theatre | 09/25/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | canary balding fortuitous meteor | 01/30/20 | | deranged therapy dog poop | 09/30/18 | | pink stimulating jew | 09/30/18 | | buff factory reset button | 09/30/18 | | Electric Corner Stain | 09/30/18 | | high-end native | 09/30/18 | | deranged therapy dog poop | 09/30/18 | | high-end native | 09/30/18 | | Electric Corner Stain | 10/01/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | narrow-minded cumskin | 09/30/18 | | very tactful stage | 09/30/18 | | silver flirting plaza | 04/24/23 | | glittery startled station | 09/30/18 | | Electric Corner Stain | 09/30/18 | | glittery startled station | 09/30/18 | | silver flirting plaza | 04/22/23 | | slap-happy french chef | 04/22/23 | | Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 07/26/19 | | Lascivious harsh tanning salon mental disorder | 01/29/20 | | Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 06/07/20 | | Lascivious harsh tanning salon mental disorder | 04/22/23 | | silver flirting plaza | 04/22/23 | | Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 04/22/23 | | slap-happy french chef | 04/22/23 | | Appetizing House | 04/22/23 | | Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 04/22/23 | | vibrant territorial shrine | 04/22/23 | | vigorous offensive genital piercing potus | 04/22/23 | | spruce stead | 04/22/23 | | Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 04/22/23 | | vibrant territorial shrine | 04/22/23 | | Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 04/22/23 | | Misunderstood citrine sanctuary | 04/22/23 | | Nudist Dashing Striped Hyena | 04/22/23 |
Poast new message in this thread
Date: September 24th, 2018 4:47 PM Author: Misunderstood citrine sanctuary
Rome's history was her expansion
Byzantium's history was her dismemberment by the Muslims
=(
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36879250) |
|
Date: September 24th, 2018 5:04 PM Author: high-end native
West was seen as a festering TTT by then.
All the wealth from the East was being used to defend the West at the time, especially as the border farmlands became barren and unused by the 4th century
Rome itself did not have an emperor since the 3rd century b/c it was just a terrible location for post 3rd century crises emperors, who were basically all Illyrian soldiers.
It was a natural progression of what had been going on for over a century by that point - Emperors were increasingly stationed in the frontlines, and to make it easier, Diocletian just made official what had been happening, creating multiple "emperors" that'd take care of a given region of the empire.
Before Constantine, during the Tetrarchy, Constantius (Constantine's father) ruled from Trier.
Diocletian (the "senior" emperor) ruled from Nicomedia (right across the Bosphorus from what would later be Constantinople).
Galerius ruled from Sirmium (his territory was the most idiosyncratic actually - normally when the empire had different emperors they usually divided it along the Balkans and have Greece be part of the Eastern front but Diocletian just put the most important line of defense that costs the most $$ for defense w/ 0 production - the Balkans - to Galerius and only gave him Greece and Thracia to work with)
Maximian, the Western Augustus ruled from Milan
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36879371) |
|
Date: September 24th, 2018 6:46 PM Author: high-end native
"Europe" as a geopolitical entity really didn't emerge until the fall of Rome if you think about it.
THere was a distinct Mediterranean civilization - until the Mediterranean became a border, not Mare NOstrum.
You probably felt like you were in the same civilization going from Rome to Carthage.
Can't say the same for Rome to....whatever Forest druidshit they were doing up in Berlin at the time.
Grain supply from Alexandria fed the proles of Rome, and Antioch/Alexandria were the richest areas of the Empire.
Britain was a festering TTT in decline, and especially after the 3rd century, a lot of the farmlands by the Rhine and the Danube frontier in the Western provinces were abandoned from the constant invasions.
In essense the wealth from the East basically paid for the defense in the West by the 5th century - which is why the West on its own just simply could not hold on while the East could pay off the Huns with massive amts of gold
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36879901) |
|
Date: September 27th, 2018 4:46 PM Author: high-end native
It's somewhat close to the Francophilia of the Russian nobility or the way that rich Americans looked to Britain in the 19th c.
The difference of course being that the Romans actually conquered Greece.
Maybe somewhat relevant is the Nomadic tribes that conquered china becoming "more Chinese than the Chinese themselves"
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36905548) |
|
Date: September 30th, 2018 1:44 PM Author: Outnumbered light new version abode
It makes for an interesting historical counterfactual thought experiment--how much did this cultural facet of the Roman people affect their grand strategy? What if they'd simply evolved to be more chauvanistic? Would, for example, there have been more attention paid to the possibility of expansion in northern europe, which had been dismissed as valueless, partially because of their observation on the level of available resources, but also almost definitely because there was a sort of "why bother" attitude (this comes out in Tacitus). Rome is a good case study for comparative politics here because, to your point, often when you're dealing with an elite / policy-selecting portion of a society beset by a fascination for some other culture, they're not also engaging in significant geopolitics. So you don't get to see the effects of that cultural impression in action on statecraft. In Rome, we did (if we accept the thesis).
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36927009) |
|
Date: October 21st, 2019 7:05 PM Author: high-end native
In a way, you could say the same for the Komnenian era/the Crusades for the Byzantines.
Instead of focusing on the Anatolian heartlands, the Komnenian emperors- Alexios, Ioannes & Manuel - focused on re-capturing the Holy Land & Europe (especially Sicily & Italy although it failed bigtime) rather than try to shorten the line of defense by re-capturing the Anatolian heartlands that was the basis for the Theme system that was the core of the Byzantine army during the Macedonian era.
The result was that although the Empire recovered from the fallout from Manzikert in a short time, it would never have the defensive position it held at the time of Basil II and had virtually little defense for the coastal towns that prospered under the Komnenian restoration
(Byzantium when Alexios I came to power:https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/85/Byzantiumforecrusades.jpg)
(Byzantium after Manuel's reign - https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5f/Byzantium_in_1170%283%29.PNG) - you could see that although they managed to recapture a lot of the more important towns, the jutting mass of Turkic Rum Sultanate in the middle of Anatolia was to pose a huge military problem for the empire.
Why? Because of the cultural hold that both Antioch and Jerusalem had for CHristendom
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#39009245) |
|
Date: December 10th, 2018 5:44 PM Author: high-end native
Before Manchus, before Qing.
The numerous tribes that invaded during the 4th century that now cease to exist, especially the Northern Dynasties.
Especially the Tang
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#37384669) |
Date: September 24th, 2018 4:51 PM Author: high-end native
Retarded flame.
They kept the Christendom safe from Muslims.
Without victory in Constantinople in 717 Europe was DONEHERE
Also Basil II, Ioannes Tsmiskes and Nikephoros II Phokas ("The White Death of Saracens") were pretty 180.
They even at one point retook Antioch, and even invaded Egypt under Manuel I Komnenos
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36879287) |
|
Date: September 24th, 2018 4:55 PM Author: high-end native
Bullshit - from 9th to 11th century they were on the offensive
What really ended it was the 4th Crusade.
From the Macedonian Dynasty until Battle of Manzikert was the 1st resurgence after the rise of Islam, and its 2nd resurgence was under the Komnenos.
Too bad Manuel died without a real heir - if he'd won at Myriokephalon history would be a lot different
And if you think about it Rome itself was on the defensive since... Augustus really (ok after Trajan)
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36879312) |
Date: September 24th, 2018 5:00 PM Author: ultramarine learning disabled state
I think you're overstating it. It was multiple periods of decline and expansion.
They reconquered much of the West under Justinian, lost a ton of territory to the Muslims and Bulgarians then regained it under the Macedonian emperors, lost Anatolia to the Turks then regained much of it under the Komnenoi. The dagger that made any real recovery hopeless was the Fourth Crusade. Before that they were still a great power or at times the strongest power in Europe/the ME.
There's a ton of cool history with them too. Their interactions with the barbarian empires that would be come modern Western Europe are fascinating. The story of Heraclius insane comeback against the Persians is cool as fuck. Anything involving Alexios is great. Like the rarely talked about wars against invading Norman conquerors and how those same people would eventually pass through Constantinople on the way to the First Crusade).
History of Byzantine State and Society by Warren Treadgold is a good book. It goes emperor by emperor discussing politics, society, day to day life, military campaigns etc. He's on the Byzophile side of things relative to most Byz scholars, so he puffs them up a bit. But it's a good book.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36879355) |
Date: September 24th, 2018 5:39 PM Author: Electric Corner Stain
Flame, it's a deeply heroic story. Rome was clearly supposed to fall in the early 600s. The West was already lost. The plague gutted their economy and population. Their borders were constantly penetrated by one tribe or another. Then in the early 600s there were several civil wars, paired with a massive Persian invasion that gobbled up Syria and Egypt, the two best provinces. Italy was deadweight, blown out from decades of war and menaced constantly by Lombards. The empire had one field army left. It would be entirely predictable for them to die off entirely.
But instead, Heraclius turned the tide, came back, and after decades of war, decisively crushed the Sassanid Empire. Things promptly fell back into decline, but that's beside the point. For a thousand years, the tides of history ordained that Byzantium would be swept aside, forever, but they battled back over and over again, going down in a blaze of glory in the process. The Muslims conquered for thousands of miles in every direction, sweeping up Africa, Spain, Persia, Central Asia, half of India...but for 800 years, Byzantium plugged them from entering Eastern Europe. Slavic hordes swarmed across the Danube, but could never go the last ten yards and conquer Thrace. They suffered a catastrophic defeat at Manzikert, but battled back for 150 years and undid virtually all the damage, until the 4th Crusade sacked their capital. And they STILL came back from that, got back the capital, and limped on for another TWO HUNDRED FIFTY years, longer than the US has existed, before finally actually falling.
That's inspiring, imo.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36879515) |
|
Date: September 24th, 2018 5:43 PM Author: high-end native
CR. So many moments where you'd think "oh this is when they fall"
But they come back from all that.
Now imagine being Heraclius though, and you bring back the True Cross to Jerusalem, revive the Empire after that long war w/ teh Sassanids when Rome really should've fallen then.
Then you see Khalid ibn al Walid lead his army into Yarmouk....
The feeling of loss and hopelessness after losing the Levant/Egypt must've been some next level shit
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36879540) |
|
Date: September 24th, 2018 6:39 PM Author: high-end native
It does beg an interesting question though. China also went through a similar dismemberment of an old empire by hordes of nomads, and the Empire had to move east to a different capital surrounded by water to hold on while its older cultural heartlands were now swarmed by barbarians.
Yet China after 3 centuries of warfare managed to reunite, while Byzantines never reconquered the Levant, Egypt, NA and Gaul/Spain.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36879858)
|
|
Date: September 24th, 2018 6:48 PM Author: high-end native
Which is a post-facto revisionism of Chinese history.
They think this is a natural progression - but why? There certainly were points of diversion when there could've been distinct civilizations w/ one centered around the Yangtze vs one up in Huabei
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36879920)
|
|
Date: September 25th, 2018 9:56 AM Author: high-end native
Sure - after Sui.
I'm not so sure the warlords from 4th-6th centuries necessarily felt that way, especially early on as these nomads had a different character in dealing w/ the Hans as did later nomadic invasions did (although there's been some SCHOLARSHIP done on this with the whole Sino-Barbarian Synthesis thing).
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36883755)
|
|
Date: September 25th, 2018 4:32 PM Author: high-end native
Well I was specifically talking about the time period when the Jin collapsed right after they finally ended the 3 Kingdoms Era.
A century before the Western Roman Empire fell, Jin also collapsed in a similar manner, and like 5 different states were set up in the northern plains while the Jin dynasty moved east to what is now Nanjing and only held the Yangtze River area + Jingzhou while the nomads took every land up north
These nomads had little experience ruling Han people, and were quite different in character from later dynasties like Liao - most didn't even use the title Emperor (huangdi) but used "Celestial King" (tian-wang).
These kingdoms you could probably compared to the Germano-Roman kingdoms like Visigothic Kingdom in Iberia, Vandal Africa, Ostrogothic Italy (Theodoric could probably be compared to Shi Le) and the Frankish Kingdom - barbarian leaders, native bureaucracy creating a hybrid culture.
Remember that after Han fell, China had multiple kingdoms for ~340 years if you take out the 30 years of unified Jin. Certainly enough time for an entirely new political tradition to form
Yet china still reunited. Why?
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#36886856)
|
|
Date: October 21st, 2019 7:10 PM Author: high-end native
A lot of the "Greeks" considered themselves as Romans until the 20th century.
"On 8 October 1912, during the First Balkan War, Lemnos became part of Greece. The Greek navy under Rear Admiral Pavlos Kountouriotis took it over without any casualties from the occupying Turkish Ottoman garrison, who were returned to Anatolia.
Peter Charanis, born on the island in 1908 and later a professor of Byzantine history at Rutgers University recounts when the island was occupied and Greek soldiers were sent to the villages and stationed themselves in the public squares. Some of the children ran to see what Greek soldiers looked like.
‘‘What are you looking at?’’ one of them asked.
‘‘At Hellenes,’’ the children replied.
‘‘Are you not Hellenes yourselves?’’ a soldier retorted.
‘‘No, we are Romans.""
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#39009263)
|
Date: April 22nd, 2023 4:31 AM Author: slap-happy french chef
reading about the fall and decline of the empire literally makes me weep
i.e. the things we gave up, for the trivialities that we're still stuck on to this day
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=4086319&forum_id=2#46224303) |
|
|