FATAL FLAW in THE THIRD MAN - not enough Orson Welles
| aphrodisiac jap market | 08/04/14 | | mustard seedy center dingle berry | 08/04/14 | | aphrodisiac jap market | 08/04/14 | | mustard seedy center dingle berry | 08/04/14 | | aphrodisiac jap market | 08/04/14 | | Harsh Obsidian Stain | 08/03/24 | | fishy juggernaut school cafeteria | 08/03/24 | | Harsh Obsidian Stain | 08/03/24 | | fishy juggernaut school cafeteria | 08/03/24 | | marvelous pearl gas station karate | 08/03/24 | | Zombie-like Chrome Old Irish Cottage | 08/19/24 | | Cobalt Thriller Regret Sanctuary | 08/19/24 |
Poast new message in this thread
Date: August 4th, 2014 8:05 PM Author: aphrodisiac jap market
the "unedited cut" is 104 minutes long, with maybe three minutes of orson welles talking and explaining himself. he does well in that brief time, but it's not nearly enough - we still have no real idea why harry lime did the shit he did, or how he evolved to that point.
that film should have been around 140 minutes long with lots more harry lime.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2636360&forum_id=2#26061569) |
Date: August 3rd, 2024 11:44 AM Author: Harsh Obsidian Stain
i think it works bc you don't need to sell corruption to the audience. we all feel the attraction of it.
when lime says, "see those moving dots down there? what if i offered you $20,000 and one of those dots would stop moving forever?", most people GET it.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2636360&forum_id=2#47924182) |
|
Date: August 3rd, 2024 12:03 PM Author: Harsh Obsidian Stain
cr. besides, a few things come into play here
1. audience needs to think he's alive initially, to exp the shock when his friend arrives to find he's *just* died.
2. audience needs to think he's dead after that point, to justify the main plot driver of the murder investigation
3. audience also needs to think he was a good guy, to justify his friend caring enough to seek justice
4. Orson Welles's introduction, with the cat running to him and the light coming on, is one of the greatest shock-moments in film.
5. which means you'd need to get into all the "breaking bad" narrative deep into the movie, which could only be accomplished by flash backs or long exposition. ("So you see, let me tell you how and why I broke bad....")
in other words, lol.
Its a perfect movie the way it is.
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2636360&forum_id=2#47924217) |
Date: August 3rd, 2024 2:28 PM Author: marvelous pearl gas station karate
The fatal flaw is the dreadful zither music
(http://www.autoadmit.com/thread.php?thread_id=2636360&forum_id=2#47924531)
|
|
|