Date: February 9th, 2006 12:42 PM Author: Flatulent multi-colored boltzmann garrison Subject: Johns Hopkins MA in Government
Does anyone have any thoughts about Johns Hopkins MA in Government, offered through the Kreiger School of Arts and Sciences? It is geared towards working professionals, and seems interesting. I'm curious about admissions standards, reputation, faculty, placements, etc.
Date: February 9th, 2006 5:04 PM Author: Orange Cuck School Cafeteria
If you are looking for a practical MA program I'd apply to SAIS at Johns Hopkins. Of course, that's an IR thing. I've never heard of the program you mentioned but if it's thru the Govt dept it might be more theoretical than a professional would want.
Date: February 10th, 2006 1:43 PM Author: Hairraiser Crackhouse
It's in D.C., you can do it part time, its carries the JHU name, and the faculty are almost entirely professionals from inside the beltway. Pretty solid all around, and a much better choice than GW or AU.
Date: May 3rd, 2006 1:37 PM Author: Sadistic Roommate Marketing Idea
Does anyone know anything about the general reputation of this program? The flexibility of the program (7 of 10 courses are electives), the location, and the price all appeal to me. However, despite the JHU name and the ability to take classes at SAIS, the lack of admissions requirement scares me.
How useful would this be for someone looking for work in the intelligence/defense community?
i'm actually in the same boat as you... it looks like a great program, except the admissions requirements look kinda shady. anyone else know anything about this?
Date: May 17th, 2006 6:02 AM Author: kink-friendly spectacular selfie ape
Seems like a cash cow to me. I doubt anyone has heard of it. If you want to do intelligence/defense, then SAIS would be infinitely superior. Best thing for you to do is to check out their placement record. Maybe call the graduate advisor (or the equivalent) and find out where the grads went after the program.
Date: May 17th, 2006 11:55 AM Author: opaque area Subject: Be Careful
Things may have changed, but I don't think Hopkins Government MA candidates can take classes at SAIS. The School works hard to keep class size to a minimum (an excellent policy in my opinion), so I'd be surprised if they suddenly let Hopkins Continuing Ed students start sitting in.
If you're looking at that program as a part-time, lower admission criteria, back-door to SAIS -- it isn't.
Date: May 18th, 2006 4:15 PM Author: supple psychic
I'm pretty sure the government program is not in the school of continuing/professional studies. In fact, Hopkins' continuing studies school is not that bad... its education program is ranked #32 in the education school rankings -- higher than Cornell, Rutgers, Wash U, etc.
I'm not saying it's bad...I really don't know that much about it. My point is simply that it isn't a substitute for the IR MA programs in DC.
If full-time isn't an option, I would recommend one of the other part-time programs in DC, such as GWU or the Security Studies program as Georgetown. At least those programs are clearly established and they have a night-class / part-time option. The Hopkins program seems a bid confusing to me. You'll be on the job market with an MA from Johns Hopkins in Washington DC with a focus on government and national security (let's say). Oh, so you went to SAIS? Umm, no, not exactly...
Date: May 19th, 2006 1:27 PM Author: Hairraiser Crackhouse
If you are already a government employee, unless you are planning to join the Foreign Service there is no way you could financially justify picking up a SAIS degree. First off, no one but SAIS / SFS alums care, and moreover, they are not generally the ones doing the hiring given that most agencies have specialized human resources departments. Honestly, they will see JHU, are beyond whatever that represents to them really could care less.
Also, for many federal jobs looking at where a degree is from is consider an inappropriate hiring criteria, beyond saying this person has a masters or law degree.
Date: May 19th, 2006 2:27 PM Author: useless center
As a Hopkins undergraduate alum, I think that I'm well-positioned to compare the two schools (disclaimer: I'll be at SAIS in the fall).
1. A simple search on our university-wide alumni network will yield you literally hundreds of SAIS grads in top slots at banks, non-profit orgs, international agencies, and, indeed, the U.S. government/foreign service, and these are grads who care enough to release their home phone numbers to the SAIS and undergraduate communities. A similar search on the Government M.A. program doesn't yield anything close in terms of quality (a comparison of quantity is meaningless: SAIS is older and larger than the Government M.A. program). The few headline graduates of the Government M.A. program advertised on its website are, unfortunately, outliers. The same simply could not be said of SAIS grads.
2. All of the Continuing Studies programs are widely regarded to be sub-JHU standards by the undergraduate community. All of the people I know who went there from undergrad were quintessential 'dumb jocks' with low GPAs and no job prospects.
3. Pedigree *does* count at the beginning and end of one's career. It is by no means a deciding factor, but any employer of consequence should be able to tell the difference b/w SAIS and the Continuing Studies.
If your measure of payoff is measured in terms of either (a) money or (b) power, the SAIS alumni network, I think, is concentrated in both areas. For the first measure, look at alumni giving to SAIS by SAIS grads. For the second measure, I'd try to gain access to the online Hopkins network. Given either of these two measures, I think one could very well financially justify the SAIS or SFS or Fletcher degrees. Having said that, the Government M.A. isn't a 'bad' or 'useless' degree relative to its cost. But its relative payoff is simply not nearly as high, on average, as that of SAIS.
Date: May 19th, 2006 9:15 PM Author: supple psychic
Actually, the government program is not in the school of continuing studies; it's in the school of arts and sciences' advanced division. so, the OP would not be telling employers that he/she went to the school of continuing studies.
As for the school of continuing studies (which consists of the business and education schools) -- it's obviously not as prestigious as SAIS, but it's actually really good compared to its peers. It may not be hopkins-undergrad prestigious, but #32 is a perfectly respectable rank.
I'm not an education major, but I would definitely rather go the continuing studies school than to pay like 50-75K for lower-ranked "traditional" programs (i.e. cornell, bu, wash u, syracuse, etc.).
I know tons of people in the education program at hopkins; they were perfectly smart people from Villanova/Bryn Mawr/GW/Maryland who did not want to spend 2-3x as much on a lower-ranked "traditional" degree. In addition, the school of continuing studies has a great program with Baltimore Public Schools where you can get basically get the degree for free if you commit to a certain number of years of teaching. It is definitely not for dumb people!
Date: May 20th, 2006 11:25 AM Author: useless center
Sorry about the mix-up. I tend to think about particular programs before the schools in which they're housed.
Nonetheless, I completely agree with you regarding reasons for attending each school. And those few 'dumb' people who attended them were just taking advantage of the rather low admissions standards--it certainly doesn't follow that the student body at large is 'dumb'. Also, I tend to mistakenly conflate 'intellectually incurious' with 'dumb'. The former would have been more appropriate.
What I don't agree with are posters' obtuse and absolutist comments like "If you are already a government employee, unless you are planning to join the Foreign Service there is no way you could financially justify picking up a SAIS degree." It's just incredible how sweeping and all-encompassing people's comments can get, still without a sufficient understanding of the object of their sentences. This seems evermore common these days--guess I'll just have to get used to it.
Date: May 20th, 2006 4:18 PM Author: Hairraiser Crackhouse
Your comment is reasonable, but off point. The presumption is the person is not going to leave government, but stay in it. In which case, taking time off is generally not a great idea. Prestige, private sector cache, sure SAIS wins. IR community - it's a huge boost. But if you work for Housing and Urban Development or on a Senate staff? You would be putting yourself into a lot of debt without much benefit.
Date: May 22nd, 2006 10:01 AM Author: useless center
Point taken. I had read your comment as rejecting the prospects of a current government employee going through one of the professional IR schools in order to transition into a career with an IR dimension, whether that be in finance or State.