\
  The most prestigious law school admissions discussion board in the world.
BackRefresh Options Airdrop

"Bibi" and "Bidenkot" are both trying to fleece me

...
160 IQ gopniks
  11/21/26
as are bennett, liberman, golan, etc.
יהוה
  11/21/26
i'm hitting the books on israeli politics but i'm ...
160 IQ gopniks
  11/21/26
keep in mind the haredis arent the only torah jews. the alt-...
יהוה
  11/21/26
i'm familiar with a few of the differences but there ar...
160 IQ gopniks
  11/21/26
w/r/t the yeshivas is there a popular perception that the ye...
160 IQ gopniks
  11/21/26
yes, it's a total fraud. everyone in israel knows th...
יהוה
  11/22/26
is it "safe" to discuss this stuff here or should ...
160 IQ gopniks
  11/22/26
shoot
יהוה
  11/22/26
a couple of quick ones -even substandard scholars of the te...
160 IQ gopniks
  11/22/26
you kind of have to analyze israel's recent history to ...
160 IQ gopniks
  11/21/26


Poast new message in this thread



Reply

Date: November 21st, 2026 8:45 PM
Author: 160 IQ gopniks



(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277527)



Reply

Date: November 21st, 2026 8:52 PM
Author: יהוה

as are bennett, liberman, golan, etc.

(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277546)



Reply

Date: November 21st, 2026 8:56 PM
Author: 160 IQ gopniks

i'm hitting the books on israeli politics but i'm not familiar with as many of the individual names

the hasidic arguments i heard recently about the israeli state's secularization opened my eyes to how the torah jews see the israeli state/government. these are things i'd never have considered prior

some say the era of the british mandate over israel was superior for the quality of the holiness of the land, but this can be admittedly very subjective. something about hotheads in irgun and the bedouin tribes and the cycle continuing on in the region

(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277556)



Reply

Date: November 21st, 2026 8:59 PM
Author: יהוה

keep in mind the haredis arent the only torah jews. the alt-right zionist parties (bennett, ben gvir, etc) are orthodox torah observant jews too.

you have orthodox jews with totally different ideologies. ones who think the torah says to be militant and take all arab land and kill all arabs now so the messiah can come. and ones who think the torah says hate the state of israel and take sit in yeshivas and collect more money for dem yeshiva programs and avoid the army.

(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277568)



Reply

Date: November 21st, 2026 9:05 PM
Author: 160 IQ gopniks

i'm familiar with a few of the differences but there are many camps

i think a good portion of the hasidim are effectively ungrateful for what the israeli MoD does and find themselves in a political position where they have no choice but to get bullied into compliance with things that are against the better nature by obvious iMOD stand-in parties like likud but at the same time "the yeshivas and our torah giants are the first line of defense for the jewish people" rings true both from experience and as theory. and while they're not a huge population % of the current israeli demographic makeup the concerns that they're growing and not "paying into the pot" one way or another are legitimate

the current arrangement where the US picks up much of the bill for defense in exchange for preferential access to the diaspora network is very good for the hasidim and takes quite a bit of heat off of the IDF if it's policed properly for fair dealings

one thing secularized israel probably couldn't have is some kind of rabbinical exchange commission to ensure that things like business dealings done by dual nationals in the diaspora are performed by some kind of religious legal standard for fairness and ethical trade. i hear there are enough issues as is with state integration of things as minor as kashrut certifications, as far as citizen complaints go w/r/t state-temple linkages and assemblages

the bargain being made atm with the arab parties seems like a corrupt one and is probably not going to be best for jewish interests in the near future, though it may have fruit later down the line depending on whether or not cartoon caricature arab politicians or arabs who actually feel as if they're a part of israel get in

(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277584)



Reply

Date: November 21st, 2026 9:12 PM
Author: 160 IQ gopniks

w/r/t the yeshivas is there a popular perception that the yeshiva dwellers are not truly committed to their studies? do you have situations like welfare abuse in the US where you'll have someone "on the rolls" at a job centre receiving payment but not actually in the process of searching for a job, the analogue would be someone enrolled in a yeshiva to avoid conscription but otherwise leading a normal life and not spending a reasonable schedule dedicated to producing thought and rumination on the essential texts

the image of a HaRav acting like a union boss for scholars is a comical one

(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277609)



Reply

Date: November 22nd, 2026 12:09 AM
Author: יהוה

yes, it's a total fraud.

everyone in israel knows that most of these haredim are not actually fit for full time yeshiva study for their entire 20s. they just dont all have the intellectual horsepower for it. it'd be like sending a bunch of B and C students in high school to study electrical engineering at MIT for 10 yrs -- it's just a fraud.

they're just hiding out in yeshivas to 1) avoid the army, and 2) mo money for dem programs

the whole position that most centrist israelis take is yeah fine, let's subsidize the best and brightest yeshiva scholars, but most of these fucks arent capable of a decade of f/t studying in their 20s and are better off being integrated into society and they can learn torah at night like haredis in the US do

(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277800)



Reply

Date: November 22nd, 2026 12:31 AM
Author: 160 IQ gopniks

is it "safe" to discuss this stuff here or should we find a different forum for jewish discussions

i have some pros and cons to run by you on this topic

(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277820)



Reply

Date: November 22nd, 2026 12:33 AM
Author: יהוה

shoot

(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277823)



Reply

Date: November 22nd, 2026 12:40 AM
Author: 160 IQ gopniks

a couple of quick ones

-even substandard scholars of the texts can produce a volume of thought on the matter which in and of itself produces a holiness of a lower quality. it is generally a boon to have people full time studying the religion with a mind to teach later, even if it's just within the community, SO LONG as it's being pursued with sincerity and a "heart towards god". it would be ridiculous to expect all students to reach the level of a maimonides or zalman and part of the benefit of study for people without that level of mental "cap" are simply keeping the very words of the text in the minds of people available to others, similarly to the islamics and the hafiz

-how much does the state sponsor these schools? also why the hell are jews jewing jews in the only truly jewish country so often? why is this a thing i constantly hear about

-i feel like you could come up with a yeshiva system that could pay for itself or at the very least lower the costs through certain programs. i don't see how these things are run with such financial profligacy that they bleed money to a point where the subjects of the state are complaining about their arrears due to them

(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277832)



Reply

Date: November 21st, 2026 8:59 PM
Author: 160 IQ gopniks

you kind of have to analyze israel's recent history to understand exactly how the foundation of the current state differs from the biblical incarnation and two years of history in the levant is like going through documentation of 20 in recent american history. it's exhausting even on a quiet day

(https://xoxohth.com/thread.php?thread_id=5924986&forum_id=2#50277569)