Date: November 20th, 2026 7:26 PM Author: Diamond Dallas Chad
Like I said in that other thread, the launch window blackout on user reviews saved Rockstar hundreds of millions in sales. 5.4 is actually way worse than I thought. I was expecting mid 7's.
Date: November 20th, 2026 7:29 PM Author: Diamond Dallas Chad
Not 99%, but they're going to "fortify" the review score up to an 8 or a 9.
The whole trend of deleting for "review bombing" is such bullshit, even if some of the people don't own the game. E.g. if it runs at 30fps and was transformed into a simp simulator, and 50% of the potential audience refuses to buy for that reason, and the other 50% tolerates and loves those aspects, what should the score be? The game is objectively bad. Do we only listen to the people who were willing to put up with it and bought the game, resulting in a high score for a bad game? Or do we blend their scores with the people who refused to buy for those reasons, ending up with a composite score that more accurately reflects the quality? "Protest reviews" are absolutely valid and should be included in the score.
the users, especially for a game like this, are really dumb and shouldn't be listened to. way too many from the Lowest Decile of intelligence.
professional reviewers though have crazy af biases and shouldn't be listened to either.
Like Siskel and Ebert just Reviewed Films, they didn't Worship certain kinds of shitty Films and give them good reviews. why can't we go back to that. but for Games. 90s reviewers just Reviewed Games too. and the scores were harsher back then, in accordance with Low Gen X GPAs in School. Star Fox 64 got like an 8/10 from Nintendo Power.
Date: November 20th, 2026 7:54 PM Author: Oh, you travel? ()
yeah, The Truth is somewhere in between, but there IS a cohort of very dumb and bitter people in this country who will dismiss a technological marvel and bang out a barely legible 1-star review because "you can't bang hookers" or something retarded like that. it is an unfortunate byproduct of the Internet that these people have "a voice" imo.
RDR2 was a hit, maybe because it predated the "every AAA Game is horrible" pile-on of the current zeigeist and GTA5 was a hit. and Boring works better in a western. and you can't make western writing gay, or it's hard to do anyway without making an actual gay western.
Date: November 20th, 2026 7:54 PM Author: ohnoes (🧐)
RDR2 was the most disappointing game I've ever played. I loved the first one and RDR2 was just really depressing and self-serious. RDR1 had you do shit like forrest gumping your way through the mexican revolution