In 2020 they cared about winning the Gen so they priced it as a loss-leader.
Then inflation & RAM fucked it, Todd and Phil fucked up VERY badly so management decided to do The Opposite of whatever they were doing, so they priced it like an equivalent Surface Laptop.
The reception for Starfield was spectacularly bad given the hype and how much was riding on it. Todd (Gen X) is a failure.
Phil did literally everything a redditor could possibly approve of - buying studios and letting them do whatever they wanted like a chill bro, getting rid of Exclusives, you name it, he did it. None of it worked. And all of the redditors who liked good guy Phil are like "this Indian bitch isn't bad." they have no idea wtf they're talking about.
Because of the State of Hardware Costs, the $400-500 Xbox in 2026 Loses them more money the more units that they sell. There's no amount of economies of scale or Winning the Gen that would get them to break even. When Everything is already an Xbox, they can't justify Losing more money the more Xboxes that they sell. Selling 1m $1000k Xboxes makes them more money than selling 10m $400 Xboxes.