It's particularly absurd when you consider
1. the prevailing trend in the US political system has been towards separation of church and state
2. there are plenty of non-christian, non-jewish, or unaffiliated citizens in the US who hold no attachment to prophecy or some strains of thought in historical Judaism or Christianity that call for aid to Israel
3. a hasidic argument I've heard as of late is that the secularized and militarized Israel is not the biblical Israel and the whole "Greater Israel" plan puts more jews at risk than it potentially helps. Hasidim and the "Torah Judaism" caucus have a lot of very interesting insights and I find most of them sympathetic
Plenty of pros for the alliance as well of course and I don't know where I fall on the question most days as of late. I'm sure many observant jews are also in a period of questioning likely attenuated by the endless conflict, and I do feel as though this is intentional. A constant strategy in war propaganda is keeping pressure on your domestic population to create an environment of terror that causes people to naturally seek authoritarian leadership. It also does quite a bit to quell the louder and more godly parts of the conscience.