Date: June 17th, 2026 12:55 PM Author: supple coldplay fan scourge upon the earth
Time to show off my revamped public speaking skills
It is the first round of a debate tournament, with the winner advancing.
The format is:
- 5-minute opening for each(10 min total.)
- Open Debate - 15 minutes.
- Moderator Q&A Crossfire (10 minutes)
- Open Debate (15 minutes)
- Closing Statements 5 minutes per combatant. (10 minutes)
My opponent is a military veteran who wants to argue the proposition that “You must have served in the military to vote”. Seems like a slam dunk topic to have the audience vote on my side, as long as I don't fuck it up
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:09 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
If you lose this, you should self-banish. Entirely. To a fucking cave deep in the wilderness somewhere (but away from genius bears). I mean, what the fuck
Will do. I've been grilled on TV and by a communist newspaper before, not to mention day drunk interviews with faggots. I handled myself well in all of those settings.
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:00 PM Author: supple coldplay fan scourge upon the earth
it isn't specific but my opponent is American and I am assuming it will focus on America, so it is straightforward to make the argument how unAmerican the proposition is, I.e. America was founded on no taxation without represenation and how government derives its authority from the consent of the governed
the only example of a society that functioned this way is from Starship Troopers
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:13 PM Author: controlling a virtual character on a computer
the only genuinely strong argument in principle against it (only military can vote) is that it leads to a government that's prone to warlike military adventurism and aggression
the other "arguments" against it are all pretty weak and can all be boiled down to "erm but literally everyone should be able to vote because that's....that's just what heckin democracy is, okay??!" which everyone who watches this debate will know is fake and gay
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:36 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
Do you feel the same way about "only people with a government job should vote" or "only people who graduated from college" or [insert whatever arbitrary class here]?
The only good argument against that is a fairness of access/democratic principle argument?
I think there are economic distortion arguments, the ability to unfairly punish and mistreat the people funneled into the system that we know the government would use (opportunities to systematically purge/destroy people with certain beliefs by sending them into danger, etc.), and more.
Am I smoking crack, or are you guys just unimaginative?
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:52 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
Thought you were saying you agree the counter comes down only to "but what about fairness," (other than having a more martially-inclined government). Felt like I was in bizarro world for a moment
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:50 PM Author: controlling a virtual character on a computer
Everything in your last paragraph boils down to “no one should ever have power over anyone else because they might abuse it for their own gain” which is just silly
We’re concerned with the specific outcomes. In this case it’s only military members voting vs everyone voting. Which one would lead to a better outcome? Right now it would be only military voting. That’s because military members are better people than the entire population in the aggregate
That doesn’t mean that there couldn’t be specifically undesirable outcomes from specifically only military members voting. Eg militaristic government. That’s the effective argument against it. Even if that outcome wouldn’t be worse than universal suffrage, it’s still the strongest argument in principle
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:03 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
I didn't lay out a systematic explanation or enumeration of the issues that I believe fall outside of the UDCU as you put it. I'm also not sure how you got "people might abuse it for their own gain"as the distillation of those few reasons I gave, particularly around the second order economic distortions that the system would create. But I'm not trying to have a full-blown textual debate about this
I really just wanted to know if you lacked imagination, and you've confirmed it
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:11 PM Author: controlling a virtual character on a computer
Lol
This is why I have all your monikers blocked on my home pc
You are just a dishonest Jewish faggot who is unable to engage in even basic good faith conversation about anything, even some random topic you have zero interest or stake in
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:56 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
LOL wow, holy shit. Out of all the things to crash out over on XO, you blew a gasket because I very gently probed whether you were running flame or genuinely lacked imagination
It's a good idea to add my moniker to your list. Don't pause for even a moment to reflect whether you're just a dumb retard with the mental flexibility of a cantaloupe
Date: June 17th, 2026 10:03 PM Author: Odious pearl haunted graveyard stage
Karlstack should say it is a bad idea because military members are suckers and losers and generally retarded so the rule would exclude the best voters.
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:38 PM Author: controlling a virtual character on a computer
Why would only people with black hair voting be worse in principle than everyone voting
Unless people with black hair are for some reason net worse people than the entire population in the aggregate, it wouldn’t lead to worse outcomes
This is the kind of thing that no one ever actually Thinks about because they’re so mind raped by individualism and “democracy” that their brains simply cannot grasp anything outside of the Universal Democracy Cinematic Universe
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:49 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
I don't think universal democracy is the right approach. Restrictions should exist in a designed and intelligent way that picking immutable characteristics like black hair or pushing people into the military will not achieve
My goal was really just to see if appeals to fairness or the UDCU are the extent of the arguments you see against this type of arbitrary design. And it seems like you've confirmed that
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:03 PM Author: controlling a virtual character on a computer
We’re talking about a specific debate question: which setup leads to a better outcome: universal democracy or only military members voting?
That’s great that you can think of other setups that would be better than either of these. So can I. It’s irrelevant
The side in favor of universal democracy in this particular debate question is much harder than it seems. There’s really only one effective argument that I already laid out above
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:06 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
I'm not talking about other setups. I mentioned the black hair thing just to see if it would help you peer around the corner a bit better
To be clear, what I'm saying is that if you believe that the only counter to the actual prompt for karlstack other than "we'd have a more militarized government" is "but what about fairness," you lack imagination and should stay away from debating
Date: June 20th, 2026 12:03 PM Author: Slippery Sick University
What? There are stronger arguments against it than saying "the country might become more warlike". Biggest one being anti-capture. You cant see how having the same class of people connected to the state’s organized force as being the only people authorized to choose a civilian government as being an issue? It would be like normal capture where politicians are optimizing for that one's group's interest but even worse, because the group also controls the military power.
Here are the strongest arguments someone would make against requiring military service to vote:
**It violates democratic principles.** Legitimate government depends on the consent of the governed. If a group is bound by laws and taxes but denied a say in making them, that's the classic "taxation without representation" problem. Civilians fund the military, the government, and public institutions through taxes—excluding them from voting breaks the basic compact of democracy.
**It excludes huge portions of the population unfairly.** Many people physically cannot serve (disabilities, medical conditions), or are barred for reasons unrelated to civic worth. The elderly, many women historically, conscientious objectors, and essential civilian workers (doctors, teachers, farmers) would all lose their voice despite contributing enormously to society.
**It creates a dangerous concentration of power.** Restricting the vote to the military risks turning a democracy toward a military oligarchy or junta. The military becomes the only group able to choose leaders, which removes civilian checks on military power—the exact opposite of how stable democracies keep armed forces accountable to elected civilians.
**Service isn't the only form of civic contribution.** Nurses, firefighters, volunteers, caregivers, and taxpayers all sustain the nation. Singling out one form of service as the sole gateway to citizenship rights is arbitrary and devalues every other contribution.
**It could distort military recruitment and motives.** People might enlist to gain the vote rather than out of genuine commitment, and the policy could be used to coerce or pressure citizens into service.
**It contradicts equality under the law.** Most modern constitutions and human-rights frameworks treat voting as a universal right of adult citizens, not a privilege earned through a specific job.
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:25 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
The fact that he is a vet almost guarantees that he's going to take this personally and resort to emotional appeals from his own set of real or imagined circumstances without realizing what a bitch move it is
Please someone have a thread bump the day of. I actually really want to see it, but I know I'll lose track
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:54 PM Author: chestnut razzmatazz giraffe state
Karlstack can wave that off as anecdotal evidence offered by someone with a self-serving agenda. Every time this guy talks about himself he's not talking about the millions of other veterans who would be the actual decisionmakers.
Date: June 17th, 2026 3:28 PM Author: Dashing drab stag film
I'm going to give it a shot without POASTERS involved and work out the kinks but if it goes well enough for me to stick with it, I'll eventually link you guys. I figure social media is one of the only ways to maek it on your own terms (see: Karlstack) so I'd be retarded not to at least try it while I'm funemployed.
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:33 PM Author: supple coldplay fan scourge upon the earth
my opponent tweeted out these arguments recently, so I am guessing these are the same ones he will make on Friday:
- No skin in the game? No power over the game.
- I think that one must first demonstrate the power and responsibility that comes with voting before giving them the right to vote… You have to demonstrate that you could pass a driving test before operating a vehicle. The principle is the same shouldn’t be no different.
-The principle is that they should have to put some skin in the game like the military in order to vote that says that they are wanting the best for the nation not the best for their individual self
- The most effective way to fix voter fraud is simple: Make voting require skin in the game. f your vote gives you power over the lives, taxes, borders, laws, and wars of other citizens, then you should first prove you’re invested in the nation you’re helping govern. Voting shouldn’t be a casual opinion poll. It should be earned authority.
- Want to vote? Earn it. If you’re willing to let politicians decide war, taxes, spending, and the future of the country, you should have demonstrated you’re willing to sacrifice something for that country first. Military service proves commitment. Voting shouldn’t be a participation trophy. Citizenship comes with rights. Real citizenship should come with responsibilities too.
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:40 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
If you blow this, debate just isn't for you. I wouldn't game it if it were me, but you could probably fuck him up by tweeting out a fake line of thought (don't fall for the possibility he has done this...be prepared for other lines of attack)
Date: June 20th, 2026 11:20 PM Author: Trip soggy institution
yes, this would make for a much more interesting debate
limiting the vote to people who pay taxes
now we are talking about contributors. far stronger and easier argument to make than durr durr military service! i'm not saying it is a winning argument, but it is an actual argument
Date: June 17th, 2026 1:42 PM Author: chestnut razzmatazz giraffe state
What problem would be solved by restricting the vote to military only? Does he think we would get better leaders?
For that matter, isn't one of the defining characteristics of military service that one must obey a hierarchical command structure? Military service can vary widely, with many troops being nothing more than glorified janitors, yet obedience to authority is something they all have in common
So this proposal would restrict voting to people who have only ever obeyed authority, usually without question. Nothing about their military experience would have prepared them to choose among leaders or to question the wisdom of the people giving orders. This proposal effectively treats the right to vote as a symbolic reward for enlisting, without any practical benefit to society or any conceivable improvement in governance.
Finally, the act of enlisting involves surrendering a number of constitutional protections and agreeing to become bound by 10 USC and the UCMJ. Why give the right to vote to a class of people who have already surrendered fundamental liberties the rest of us enjoy? Haven't they already shown that they value those liberties less than we do?
It's primarily about skin in the game and demonstrating your civic virtue. A functioning Democracy requires this and the franchise was restricted in all sorts of ways until recently. People here often say voting should be restricted to property owning white men. Military accomplishes the goals underlying this in a much more egalitarian and personal way.
That has nothing to do with what I just said. My point in referencing white male property owners is that the franchise was restricted in imperfect ways, including immutable things like race and gender.
If I was debating you I'd point out how you've missed the point to embarass you, and then I'd argue that it would be a good thing to get more whites into the military, and encourging civic service is obviously a huge component of the policy.
Do I really need to state explicitly that requiring military service in order to vote is retarded? I'm conjuring up the best argument in favor of it, not sincerely arguing for it.
Date: June 17th, 2026 3:43 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
I think all of these people will be susceptible to major disruption if you hit them from a blind spot, like the goof above who crashed out over the inability to see beyond the idea that "this all boils down to democratic fairness."
I don't think your opponent or almost anyone is thinking about other angles, like the severe socioeconomic distortions that driving more people into the military would have.
Think about it: who pays for the military? Largely the non-military taxpayer. The military at its current size, and without the prestige of being the sole voters, commands $1.5 trillion in funding right now. Pushing more people into the military will cause that to go up substantially to pay for more troops, more equipment, etc. and that's assuming there aren't even more wars as a result. As the sole voters, politicians will curry favor by showering them with more wealth, benefits, etc. to win votes, further exacerbating the economic imbalance
Who pays for that? The I-don't-even-get-a-vote taxpayer. That means their benefits will have to be cut substantially, or their taxes will have to go up substantially, and likely a combination of both. What does that do for social cohesion? What does that do for economic fairness? How is creating a large underclass of workers whose wealth is extracted without a say the right thing to do after fighting a war to end slavery?
Note as well that it's also fundamentally anti-American. I'd hit him with a quip about that in the free form debate portion ("No taxation without representation" is the very idea that birthed our great nation, and yet here you are, arguing for exactly the opposite. I don't think you know better than our founders. It all sounds fundamentally un-American to me")
I'm not saying to run through all of this (definitely don't). I'm just trying to show how there are some other angles that he might be completely unprepared for
Date: June 17th, 2026 5:42 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
I still like the economic angle because it allows you to agree with him that "skin in the game" should control, as long as you can demonstrate that under his system, the people with the most skin in the game are those who won't be able to vote. I think technology is another weak point, because fighting forces are clearly and rapidly moving towards autonomous machines. Are they going to get to vote instead? Will it shift to engineers? His view is myopic and won't last more than a few decades
Lay out your case Karl, what are you going to say 1.) in response to his arguments and 2.) with your own contentions and 3.) what is your Value going to be
PS: You should do some research into Lincoln Douglas Value debate format if you haven't already
Seriously, take us up on crowdsourcing your responses, Karlstack. The collective intelligence on xo is at least two standard deviations above any of the contenders' singular intelligence.
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:03 PM Author: supple coldplay fan scourge upon the earth
I am preparing my notes/talking points now, I have all Wednesday and Thursday to work on it so that should be plenty of time before Friday
My opponent will argue about duty, sacrifice, and honor etc. but I will not focus on these high minded ideals at the start of my opening statement, instead I will begin by walking through the practical realities
Consider some of the Americans who would no longer be permitted to vote:
A farmer could work fourteen-hour days, from sunrise to sunset, feeding me, feeding you, and feeding families he will never meet.
I could not look that farmer in the eye and say:
“You feed this country. You pay taxes. You obey its laws. Your land is regulated. Your equipment is taxed. Your livelihood is shaped by trade policy, environmental policy, fuel prices, and inflation—but you have no right to vote for the people making those decisions.”
Likewise a hospice worker can bathe your dying mother, feed her, comfort her, administer her medication, and sit beside her during the final hours of her life... etc.
then after I walk through a few of these practical examples I will pivot to talking about different types sacrifice, democracy, etc.
My opponent is a hardcore protestant so one thing I was wondering if I should bring up is the obvious fact that Jesus Christ would disagree with him... or maybe bringing religion into it is a bad idea
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:12 PM Author: Canary potus
not a single member of this audience is going to care about an hospice worker. you are way too canadian to do this. you do not appeal to emotion with an american audience.
the farmer thing works except we dont have them anymore, but it conceptually works. that should be your only point and then you should refuse to speak again because you are only going to fuck it up and the more you talk the more they are going to realise you are autistic and canadian
All of those are good points. Don't go into relgion--you don't need to. But if you do, highlight the religion our military disproportionately serves. You would have to.
I don't mind some of this rhetoric, but it's completely unstructured and just gawking at his arguments isn't going to be sufficient for winning the debate.
If I was in your shoes, I would adopt a Value of Human Florishing with a Criterion of Protecting Political Agency. The overhead argument would be we want people to be living full lives and the way that is accomplished is by allowing people to have agency over their lives. You then say whichever side gives people more agency should win the round.
Then you hit them with two contentions:
C1: Severed political agency for the governed destroys human flourishing
C2: A military-only electorate maximizes militarism and lets the government manufacture its own voters which corrodes flourishing at scale
I think you're in good shape arguments-wise, but the blackpill about public debates is that they're won by whoever is "perceived" as more credible. Luckily for you, your opponent is an overemotional GWOT retard which means you should be able to seem more balanced than him almost immediately, but he will almost certainly come across more convicted in his position naturally. Don't underestimate him, but as long as you don't stutter and cower before him, you'll win.
You should just be repeating self-affirmations before the round: "I will not be MOGGED. I will not be MOGGED."
i liked your argument and find your post interesting.
but no idea why anyone in a debate would grant you this, you can make up all sorts of stuff in an abstract framework like this
"The overhead argument would be we want people to be living full lives and the way that is accomplished is by allowing people to have agency over their lives. You then say whichever side gives people more agency should win the round."
Date: June 17th, 2026 4:12 PM Author: talented yarmulke
In all sincerity, without any malice: you are going to get raped if you don't get a lot better at argumentation between now and then.
What you have right now is retarded emotional tripe without any real reasoning. It boils down to "everyone who pays taxes and is generally a good person has as much right to vote as anyone else."
— you haven't proposed any specific definitions for the terms in there, which a smart opponent will challenge
— you're going to struggle a lot if someone smart says "being a good person does not make someone a good voter" and lays out a case in depth
— I suspect you're not well prepared to argue about metrics for skin in the game, time preference, or commitment to the country
1. Win conditions are everything. You need to explicitly lay out a criteria for the arbiter to decide the winner. This should be reasonable, it should be highly defensible...and of course it should be something you meet better than your opponent.
2. You need a LOT more depth. If I can accurately sum up your position in two sentences, you need more arguments. You'd benefit a lot from analysis of:
— purposes of voting
— good reasons for barriers to voting
— why this is the wrong one
— lots of impacts
3. None of this is impacted at all. "I couldn't look that farmer in the eye" dies fast to "because you lack the will to enforce good governance, but I don't! Here are five reasons that it's better for the country to do this, regardless of my opponent's excess emotion..." Instead you need to give us tangible reasons to care rather than the vaginal secretions you've outlined above.
If you want to actually get good at this, you need to look at:
— team policy debate theory (ignoring the kritikal affs that have been in vogue since the 90s; look up actual policy theory)
— Lincoln Douglas value debate case structure
— American parliamentary debate format and prep, and different case structures
Last bit of free help: this is a policy resolution with a very narrow scope so you should structure this mostly as a parli case, you should have a clear framework that will function as a win condition, you should have at least one contention that relies on American founders and their writing so you can preempt "muh patriotism," you should explore several alternative barriers or requirements for suffrage to test against your opponent's case, and you should extrapolate all arguments to real world consequences (which you link back to your framework).
I love you as a poaster and friend, but have to disagree with almost everything beyond your first sentence here.
1. No one cares about definitions and if karlstack spergs out and argues about definitions, he will be laughed at and will lose.
2. While I agree that being a good person doesn't mean one will be a good voter, there is a lot of overlap between the two. Indeed, avoiding the topic altogether is tcr.
3. On the contrary, I believe Karlstack is well-equipped to make the argument about skin in the game. I think I could make a better argument, though, based on my experiences. I never served (and truly regret not having been a PJ), but at the same time, I think civil service counts just as much (if not more!) than military service. At least civil servants are serving their own communities and their own people.
4. I completely agree with you on setting the metrics for winning straight.
5. No one at this debate will even know the difference between lincoln-douglas, public forum, and policy debates.
Date: June 17th, 2026 4:33 PM Author: carnelian stead trust fund
I think you mean you regret never trying to become a para jumper. Becoming a para jumper is extremely difficult with a high attrition rate. Lots of extremely fit bros don't make it.
yeah, 100%. No idea whether I would've made the cut, but I think back then I had what it takes. I became a paramedic while also a full-time double engineering major. That also takes a fuck ton of work. I also ran a marathon during that time, so I was in pretty great physical shape.
Date: June 17th, 2026 4:39 PM Author: talented yarmulke
1. Talking about definitions doesn't have to be spergy. For me, beating other people on definitions usually looked like "this could mean a lot of things so here's what we think it should mean, and why" instead of "DEFINITION 1: GOOD PEOPLE...REASON TO PREFER 1:..." Additionally, my point here is more that he needs to rely on less nebulous vibe based "argumentation" — a definitions argument doesn't happen when he instead leads with: "the way you should measure what's best for the country is broad based representation. This is because it ensures governmental sustainability, limits fast sweeping change, and reduces polarization at the highest levels of government." No ambiguity there, definitions argument has already been made, but only his opponent is going to look gay for pulling out a dictionary.
2. Wrong! He needs to give "good person" a lot more flesh and bones. "Community involvement over a long period of time, demonstrated ability to think long-term, and service to others all combine to indicate that someone is likely to be a good voter: they care about their country and the people around them, and are less likely to be impulsive or make rash decisions." He needs to make the same argument with a lot more depth, and then impact it. But that's only one contention. It's far from enough.
3. You're missing my point here: it's not that his side isn't conducive to making that argument, it's that he needs to intentionally and specifically prep that out a lot, because it's the crux of his opponent's case. He needs to link turn basically everything, and walk through a response tree so he's over prepared on this.
5. Obviously — but being good at any of them will have you dominating here if you can speak well, and understanding policy arg theory and LD/parli case structure will give him a huge advantage in how he orders his presentation.
6. I am phone—poasting and love my long-press full em—dashes — — — and I wish I could more easily do them on my computer — — — —
Sorry, I saw the em-dash and immediately thought ChatGPT.
1. I'm hesitant to give him the benefit of the doubt when it comes to not sounding spergy here. It's tough to accomplish in the way you described, but if there's anyone who can do it, it's our boy Karl "Kike" Stack.
2. I think this is the point you and I disagree the most on: To what extent are grunts allowed to demonstrate their ability to "think long-term"? Isn't the whole idea that they're *not* supposed to think? They just follow orders, regardless of the order.
Date: June 17th, 2026 4:57 PM Author: talented yarmulke
1. People are naturally sympathetic to definitions arguments when there's real ambiguity or equivocation. You just have to not be a faggot about it. Adopt the vibe, "let's be real here, this could mean anything to anybody — you know it, I know it, so let's just make this easier on ourselves by clarifying what it means right now."
2. ...which is why this is an argument where he can turn everything Aff says.
— start by outlining what makes a good voter. Rely on historical analysis, from Athens to the founders. Federalists 10, 55, 57, as well as Adams and Jefferson letters to each other and to others would be great here.
— then apply those traits to the military and naturally show ways in which the military exhibits some, but not all. "Some soldiers have these things, some don't. Some civilians have these traits, some don't. Service is an imprecise barrier, and excludes many that Madison, Jefferson, and Hamilton all wanted to help shape our government. We need soldiers to vote, but we also need entrepreneurs, doctors, preachers, and firefighters."
Date: June 17th, 2026 4:35 PM Author: carnelian stead trust fund
Of course I am serious. Hegemon is completely right. Especially with summing up karlstacks argument as 'hey this good person won't be allowed to vote are u serious?' Any competent debater familiar with what Hegemon posted will destroy karlstack.
Date: June 20th, 2026 11:26 PM Author: Trip soggy institution
every one of your durr durr jobs who would no longer be permitted to vote are jobs that one can have in the military. i assume they also have durr durr hospice workers, but someone else rightly called you out on that one
The audience for this thing must be absolute morons so Karlstack getting BTFO might actually be a good thing.
Debates should be about performance, not choosing a topic most people already agree with. That's why every serious format have them argue the contra position as well. What a fucking shitshow lmao.
Yeah I mean think of the debate slop the audience and participants must consume. It's gonna be all Asmongold and Destiny types except way less charasmatic and intelligent (as terrifying as that is.)
Date: June 17th, 2026 3:13 PM Author: Fucking Fuckface
You're on to something with the moron thing, because I'm finding this whole thing really interesting. I'd even listen to you and Karlstack debate right now if you motherfuckers were doing one
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:01 PM Author: Galvanic skinny woman
Good luck man. You’re going to do great. I used to do debate in college and sometimes I’ll see a guy on the street and we’ll just get into it. Like really go at each other
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:08 PM Author: supple coldplay fan scourge upon the earth
Jews serve in the military like 500% less than their proportion in society so I thought about making a jokey argument about anti-semitism but decided against it
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:14 PM Author: chestnut razzmatazz giraffe state
There are more of them than you might think, although they all go through ROTC/OCS and become officers. I've personally known a jewish Army colonel and a Jewish Navy F-18 pilot
I have only known one jew military guy. He got a fuck up discharge from the national guard and claims he was special forces. I had to talk a black Ranger out of beating the absolute shit out of him at a bar once.
Date: June 17th, 2026 2:29 PM Author: Canary potus
still you can put him on the spot and ruin his entire life. sealclubber and MANY other xo posters and the entire internet will back you up on the simple proposition that only jews should be able to vote in us elections
Date: June 17th, 2026 4:38 PM Author: nofapping exhilarant alpha
ooh, take a quick look at how Sparta ran things and how the military needed a slave class with no rights. might make for an impressive allusion if done well.
Date: June 17th, 2026 4:51 PM Author: Canary potus
Hegemon is a military meathead who probably agrees with your opponent but still was able to lay it out in a way that this Canadian interloper will fail terribly
Date: June 17th, 2026 4:53 PM Author: carnelian stead trust fund
Karlstack is gonna get blown out because he is starting from the premise of "democracy is good" and from there "the more democratic it is, the better".
Any competent debater will immediately undermine the pro-democratic presumption.
Date: June 17th, 2026 4:58 PM Author: carnelian stead trust fund
would be pretty funny if he conceded his central premise off the bat by taking the position that universal voting is a bad idea because of diversity. i wonder what that means for his position that voting should not be limited to military.
Date: June 17th, 2026 6:17 PM Author: chestnut razzmatazz giraffe state
Karlstack has the advantage of not having to justify his position because it's already the status quo. He wins by keeping the burden on the side arguing for change to explain why change is necessary. Karlstack has to avoid inadvertently assuming the burden of proof, and he can't let his opponent flip things around and force him to defend the status quo. He really should put the other guy on the defensive right out of the gate and interrogate him
Date: June 18th, 2026 7:24 AM Author: excitant brindle newt market
The best arguments for restricting the vote to vets are better arguments for compulsory military service--a much more moderate position to take and one that's not uncommon across the world--yet that's not what he wants. Which means he will almost certainly be arguing (not necessarily explicitly of course) from some position of self superiority, and whenever he exposes that you seize on it.
The Federalist papers/constitutional convention/jefferson's letters have stuff about dangers of standing army
Jefferson's inaugural address - a jealous care of the right of election by the people -- a mild and safe corrective of abuses which are lopped by the sword of revolution where peaceable remedies are unprovided; absolute acquiescence in the decisions of the majority, the vital principle of republics, from which is no appeal but to force, the vital principle and immediate parent of despotism; a well-disciplined militia, our best reliance in peace and for the first moments of war till regulars may relieve them; the supremacy of the civil over the military authority;
Madison at the Constitutional Convention: "In time of actual war, great discretionary powers are constantly given to the Executive Magistrate. Constant apprehension of war, has the same tendency to render the head too large for the body. A standing military force, with an overgrown Executive will not long be safe companions to liberty. The means of defence agst. foreign danger, have been always the instruments of tyranny at home. Among the Romans it was a standing maxim to excite a war, whenever a revolt was apprehended. Throughout all Europe, the armies kept up under the pretext of defending, have enslaved the people. "
Mason's Virginia convention proposal - "that Standing Armies in Time of Peace are dangerous to Liberty, and therefore ought to be avoided as far as the Circumstances and Protection of the Community will admit; and that in all Cases, the Military should be under strict Subordination to, and governed by the Civil Power"
Madison in federalist no 41 - "the liberties of Rome proved the final victim to her military triumphs; and ... the liberties of Europe, as far as they ever existed, have, with few exceptions, been the price of her military establishments"
Hamilton in federalist no 8 - There is a wide difference, also, between military establishments in a country seldom exposed by its situation to internal invasions, and in one which is often subject to them, and always apprehensive of them. The rulers of the former can have a good pretext, if they are even so inclined, to keep on foot armies so numerous as must of necessity be maintained in the latter. These armies being, in the first case, rarely, if at all, called into activity for interior defense, the people are in no danger of being broken to military subordination. The laws are not accustomed to relaxations, in favor of military exigencies; the civil state remains in full vigor, neither corrupted, nor confounded with the principles or propensities of the other state. The smallness of the army renders the natural strength of the community an over-match for it; and the citizens, not habituated to look up to the military power for protection, or to submit to its oppressions, neither love nor fear the soldiery; they view them with a spirit of jealous acquiescence in a necessary evil, and stand ready to resist a power which they suppose may be exerted to the prejudice of their rights. The army under such circumstances may usefully aid the magistrate to suppress a small faction, or an occasional mob, or insurrection; but it will be unable to enforce encroachments against the united efforts of the great body of the people.
In a country in the predicament last described, the contrary of all this happens. The perpetual menacings of danger oblige the government to be always prepared to repel it; its armies must be numerous enough for instant defense. The continual necessity for their services enhances the importance of the soldier, and proportionably degrades the condition of the citizen. The military state becomes elevated above the civil. The inhabitants of territories, often the theatre of war, are unavoidably subjected to frequent infringements on their rights, which serve to weaken their sense of those rights; and by degrees the people are brought to consider the soldiery not only as their protectors, but as their superiors. The transition from this disposition to that of considering them masters, is neither remote nor difficult; but it is very difficult to prevail upon a people under such impressions, to make a bold or effectual resistance to usurpations supported by the military power.
Date: June 18th, 2026 1:56 PM Author: chestnut razzmatazz giraffe state
"Standing army" meant something different in the 18th century from what it means today. I'd avoid using that phrase, especially since the Constitution authorizes Congress to raise an army