Date: November 15th, 2026 9:38 PM Author: The Penis
I don’t think phenomenological stuff belongs. My list is Aristotle, Plato, Leibniz, Kant, Descartes, Spinoza. Then after probably some 20th century guys like David Lewis, kit fine, Kripke, Armstrong, probably a few others. I’m most confident about my T3. I think Aristotle as 1 and Plato as 2 isn’t really contestable. Kant vs. Leibniz for 3 reasonable people can disagree on, but Kant was more influential in epistemology really, Leibniz was more of a metaphysicans metaphysician. I have other reasons for him above Kant too.
Date: November 15th, 2026 10:12 PM Author: The Penis
The concepts in metaphysics are made up by humans, but they are constrained by objective relationships and structure. Same goes for pure math, they just have stronger methods for establishing the validity of their conclusions. Engineers make up techniques. Physicists invent models. A bridge design is made up by humans. Nature doesn't contain a blueprint specifying how to build a suspension bridge, but once you go to make one its structural properties are constrained by physical reality. You don’t think metaphysics is the same? The frameworks for something like “causation” are human invented but obviously they are constrained by relationships between actual physical events, variables etc, even if not uniquely determined.
Date: November 15th, 2026 10:20 PM Author: You're all a bunch of thespians.
there are no right answers in philosophy of mind because there are no Truth Makers. Anything that has a truth maker is science. Anything that doesn't is philosophy. That's the definition of metaphysics.
Date: November 15th, 2026 10:29 PM Author: The Penis
The problems they are trying to solve are difficult, the universe is complicated, and our understanding is incomplete. Just because we havent figured everything out doesnt mean there are no constraints. A lot of that stuff is underdetermined proto-knowledge that will eventually resolve into other disciplines or better concepts
Date: November 15th, 2026 10:30 PM Author: You're all a bunch of thespians.
exactly, once there is an objective constraint its no longer philosophy. philosophy has few if any objective constraints. that's the definition of metaphysics.
Date: November 15th, 2026 10:38 PM Author: The Penis
You are treating “objectively constrained” as meaning having a uniquely determined, demonstrably correct answer. That’s not really what it means. Objectively constrained just means that there are logical constraints that exist independently that limit possible answers. If some possible accounts are incompatible with logic, evidence, or the actual structure of reality then it is objectively constrained. Just because the constraints we currently know of and can conceptualize don’t currently eliminate every competing theory except one right one doesn’t meant it isn’t constrained at all.
Date: November 15th, 2026 10:21 PM Author: Brussels Sprout (Apropos of the Wet Snow)
that's like saying the last great metaphysician of the western canon who explicitly warned about technology and the death of being doesn't matter-- please stick to your TTT undergrad simplifications