Date: December 3rd, 2005 1:49 AM Author: chocolate indecent sneaky criminal
I'm going to say Plato. I think he's brilliant. I don't much about the more modern philosopher though... I'm sorta partial to the Ancients I think. How is Marx and Hegel?
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:52 AM Author: talented philosopher-king lay
he was supposed to give a set of lectures at my undergrad my senior year...but then he couldn't becaues he was getting treated for cancer, then he died. I was pissed.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:14 AM Author: Bat Shit Crazy Razzmatazz Resort Ape
Yeah, I agree with you about that - I like Mill's sensibly liberal perspective. He'd probably be a cool guy to drink with, whereas Hobbes (a prune) would get annoyed and stay home.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:11 AM Author: Motley ruddy circlehead kitchen
Why Mill? I was supposed to read the guy last semester... have no clue what he's about except that he was all for liberty... or was that Locke. No, I was supposed to read Locke actually. So why is Mill > Locke?
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:13 AM Author: bateful aqua jew spot
mill is important because, among other things, he believed that you should be able to do what ever the hell you wanted free of state restriction as long as you didn't harm anyone else. also, he was a great champion of women's rights.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:15 AM Author: Bat Shit Crazy Razzmatazz Resort Ape
Yeah, pretty much Mill has very sensible, modern ideas that are impressive for his time & place - respect for women, other religions, personal freedom...
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:19 AM Author: Motley ruddy circlehead kitchen
not so, my friend. I have the whole Christmas break to read Mill, and whoever else we studied first term. (edit: Rousseau's "First and Second Discourses and "On the Social Contract.") Will reading those 3 works in 3 weeks be OK? I have to write a comparative essay on 2 of those works.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:22 AM Author: bateful aqua jew spot
yeah. just skim them to get their flavor, and use like wikipedia or the plato data base at stanford to get the particulars down for you paper. hell, i put a lot of effort in to reading that shit back in the day, and i forgot everthing already.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:18 AM Author: judgmental faggot firefighter
because mill actually reasons things out and has a pragmatic approach to justifying liberty
locke just says that certain rights come down from god and thus everyone should be free, a la the constitution and declaration of independence. no kind of real argument there. just a statement.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:46 AM Author: Motley ruddy circlehead kitchen
ok. Do you think I can ace the essay using this method though? I committed myself to getting an A in this course.. sorta. It's my easiest course thus far, which is why I've been slacking big time...
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:32 AM Author: bateful aqua jew spot
that's a lot of pages to read. but the take home ideas aren't super sophisticated. use a website that summarizes for you, then cross reference to the text in your paper (giving lots of cites makes it look like you read a lot).
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:34 AM Author: Motley ruddy circlehead kitchen
are they easy to read? Is Rousseau & Locke easier than Hobbes? I found Hobbes quite difficult last year. What about Marx...? I have to read the Marx-Engels reader as well. FUCK why do I procrastinate so much.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:21 AM Author: bateful aqua jew spot
yeah. pi is good. but the tractatus just give me chills. he was working on it as a troop in on the front lines in ww1. finished it in an italian prision camp.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:27 AM Author: Domesticated hospital
I've never been that impressed with Wittgenstein. Most of what he says seems fairly obvious, at least in hindsight. Very few "wow" moments reading him.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:31 AM Author: Motley ruddy circlehead kitchen
I fucking hated Rousseau. If he's the best I'm screwed. I read some of his Second Discourses and I think I might have read Social Contract.. probably not. Are they generally easy to skim??
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:33 AM Author: Domesticated hospital
Actually, I honestly can't remember. It's been several years since I read any of them, but I do remember them all being interminably boring. I liked Rousseau the best, but that might be just be his philosopy, and not the actual process of slogging through his books.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:38 AM Author: appetizing mediation
Dennet might turn out to be an important philosopher (he's certainly been responded to in all the major debates he's entered). He's also an incredibly popular contemporary philosopher, as far as that goes.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:44 AM Author: Domesticated hospital
He's an interesting writer. His books are certainly crammed full of information. I get the impression though that the positions he's staked in the various debates aren't found to be all that compelling by most of his colleagues. I've really only studied his philosophy of mind stuff in any detail, and there's something pretty significant lacking there.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:49 AM Author: appetizing mediation
Philosophy of mind/cogsci is pretty much what Dennet has written on seriously, as I understand it, although staking out ground in philosophy of science along the way. Anyway, philosophers don't like Dennet, in my opinion, largely because if he's right about many of the things he thinks he's right about, then they're all talking a lot of rot.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:55 AM Author: bateful aqua jew spot
the best philosophers are the philosophers who come along and tell other philosophers that they are talking a lot of rot. Dennet might be that guy for our time, if what you are saying is correct.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:03 AM Author: appetizing mediation
Well, it's a whole different situation in "our time." Everything is very specialized and beaurocratized, and it's just very doubtful that there will be any more important philosophers like there were in previous centuries. Arguably Quine has already pointed out the rot in the existing anglo-american tradition, and even though almost all academic philosophers regard him as one of the two or three great philosophers of the 20th c, they have largely papered over his criticisms and gone about business as usual.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:16 AM Author: appetizing mediation
Quine went to Oberlin undergrad. Also his nephew went to WUSTL law, and played guitar in the Voidoids.
Specialization has eliminated the old sort of intellectual--and good riddance, in my opinion. It won't be anyone in particular--although, of course, particular people will do important work.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:36 AM Author: Motley ruddy circlehead kitchen
Barzini, did you find Mill easy to read? Could I read all his works in essentially a week? Fucking course... the prof. is so TTT I didn't think much of it...
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:50 AM Author: appetizing mediation
Yes. I've also had profs who have more or less lectured from it. It's not bad form to use, or anything like that, although, as I say, you should read the assigned materials as well.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:55 AM Author: Motley ruddy circlehead kitchen
awesome. would you mind editing my final paper once it's done? I want another person's opinion to make sure it doesn't look like it was written last minute... which it probably will be.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:40 AM Author: bonkers spruce private investor therapy
personally, i dont have any favorites since im not that familiar with major philosophers to have an educated opinion, but from what i know id say don's selection is most amicable to my taste in thinking men. id also add Hume to the list, as i have great respect for what he has done. and maybe id even add russell to that list, not necessarily as a great philosopher, but as a great writer and champion of free thought. of course there are other men that have impressed me as much as the best philosophers have, men like newton, einstein, godel, etc.
whereas men like plato, aristotle, kant, marx and hegel i really dont have much respect for.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:48 AM Author: bonkers spruce private investor therapy
muddled thinking, basically set back progress for a very long time until people finally discarded his teachings in favor of an empirical investigation of nature.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:54 AM Author: appetizing mediation
Dude, that's just wrong. Aristotle is the original naturalist, and he made a lot of headway, given the resources available to him. What you might be thinking about is scholastic Aristotelianism--the Catholic church turned Aristotle into a mouthpiece for Catholic doctrine. But Aristotle arguably invented the kind of empirical investigation that defines scientific method today.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:13 AM Author: appetizing mediation
Well, the rationalist/empiricist traditions are traced back to Plato and Aristotle, respectively. But moreover, Aristotle just made a lot of detailed studies of the natural world, and extracted a lot of his philosophy from that--the Physics, for instance.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:01 AM Author: bonkers spruce private investor therapy
but he was wrong on so many counts, and the worst thing is that he was satisfied with his outlandish assertions without a single hint of curiosity as to whether they might even be true.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:09 AM Author: appetizing mediation
Aristotle believed a lot of crazy shit. But not any more than, say, Newton, who believed in all kinds of astrology and alchemy hocus pocus. Aristotle invented a wrong physics, and a wrong biology, to name two, but he nonetheless invented those fields, and given what was going on at the time, that's a huge accomplishment. You have to consider that Aristotle was doing his stuff in a time before anyone thought to codify generalizations on the basis of observation. That's huge.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:14 AM Author: bonkers spruce private investor therapy
id say what Galileo and Copernicus achieved, just in terms of a major leap in thinking and organizing concepts, far surpassed Aristotle. for example, before Galileo came up with the concept of inertia, it was very difficult to find a clear systematic way of explaining motion and nobody before then could even hope to do so. it just boggles my mind that we take this principle for granted, where it took a genius to come up with.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:29 AM Author: appetizing mediation
I don't think there's much value in making that sort of assesment. Galileo and Copernicus stood on Aristotle's shoulders, just like Newton stood on their shoulders, just like Einstein and others stood on his. I don't think there's anything wrong with being more interested in Galileo though.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:32 AM Author: bonkers spruce private investor therapy
hmmm, maybe, maybe. it's still hard for me to accept inferior men as being equals with the brightest stars just merely based on the fact that they came before.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:40 AM Author: appetizing mediation
I don't think that it's at all clear that Aristotle was an inferior thinker. Part of my point was that he didn't have anything like the history of discovery to support what he did, and created that history, to a large degree, for folks like Galileo. Actually, I think there's a strong case that Aristotle was superior. To put it very crudely, it's like the difference between a 172 cold, and and a 178 after months of prepping. Which is more prestigious? It's very hard to say, no?
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:51 AM Author: bonkers spruce private investor therapy
well, plato didnt really put forward any useful philosophy. he wasn't a truth seeker, and as it were, christian dogma was helped greatly by his authority to take hold of men's lives for a very long time. hegel and marx essentially created myths, or more favorably known as philosophies of history. and not only were those myths quite absurd, but they also caused a lot of harm to humanity. as for kant, well, i venture to guess that he will be a mere footnote to Hume in a thousand years time.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:57 AM Author: bateful aqua jew spot
plato is a the literal representation of the creation of the the western mind. until you can see philosophers on that level, you are just wasting your time.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:10 AM Author: Motley ruddy circlehead kitchen
Do I really seem like a poor student though? I mean I was very conscientious last year and received one of the highest marks in the class... I have to get an A on this paper as well, it's not an option at this point. I know I slacked off and made some wrong decisions, although some things were also beyond my control (medical emergency for one), but I need to do this...
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:24 AM Author: Motley ruddy circlehead kitchen
ok thanks. I'd still appreciate input on my essay if you have time over the xmas break as well... or just for ideas. I feel uncomfortable asking my prof. since he knows I slacked so much.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:05 AM Author: bonkers spruce private investor therapy
just based on the merit of his writings, what is so great about Plato that it would be absolutely necessary of the modern educated man to bother reading him? seeing as the republic was probably his most famous work, and if i can assume it represents the pinnacle of his thinking, i cant really concede to you that he represents what you claim he does.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:20 AM Author: bonkers spruce private investor therapy
face it, plato doesnt have anything of relevance to contribute when it comes to advancing our understanding of human affairs and the business of the betterment of mankind, let alone having anything to do with understanding the deep mysteries of this world. at least, that is my position.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:35 AM Author: appetizing mediation
Plato is worth reading. Most of the great philosophers are worth reading, if only to get a better sense of where various debates began, and where they might be headed. I say this as a philosophical anti-platonist.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 2:53 AM Author: razzle emerald range
dudes, bury this thread as it drives the stock of the whole board way down. i enjoy your loquacious threads on law school, but as soon as you turn to philosophy, you're strictly TTf*inT.
Here it is: Giorgio Agamben. he should be your favorite.
Im sure none of you have heard of him, esp. since you're willing to discuss Hobbes and Mill as philosophers (I'd call them political economists since, well, that's the discipline they founded. Marx/Hegel too. They weren't metaphysicians)
Also, a word to the wise: don't put legal philosophers or light weight american choice theorists in the same category as giants like Nietzsche, etc. I'm no europhile, but most everyone agrees that the american philosophical tradition got screwed up after dewey.
also, if you want something to read, look at Adorno. he's extremely acerbic, humorous, and frighteningly smart. Like an ideal XOXO poster.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:13 AM Author: razzle emerald range
bingo. and then we;d say heidegger, and then they'd say nazi!
it depresses me how little of the best thinking leaks into legal thought. I literally introduced my professors to agamben, among others. And he writes about the law! That is just pathetic. These are highly intelligent people with a reading list that so outdated its crushed by any undergrad critical theory class. When will law school academic work get any respect from the rest of the liberal arts? A: not in our lifetime.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:21 AM Author: bateful aqua jew spot
i think the idea that law is an intellectual endeavor is a fraud. and speaking of students, i would be willing to bet that even at the top schools there are very few well read people.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 3:32 AM Author: razzle emerald range
totally. it saps my will to study. the best metaphor i can think of is that a good law student is someone with great processor speed but the software sucks. they can just absorb info byte after byte and turn it around in 2-d, but they'll never get that third dimension to their thinking. and the sad thing is that that third dimension can actually be taught. they just don't want to learn anything that might actually reorganize the map of knowledge they internalized in high school.
I mean can you believe some of the stuff being written on this thread? I can just picture the brandy snifters being palmed. what a waste of brandy.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 4:17 AM Author: bateful aqua jew spot
law school is my last option. i am going to be working at a friends start up company in LA. if we pwn loser-fuckers, i'm not going to go. i'll just study some econ or something business-y, so i get some quant skills.
if i fail at this endeavor, i'll go to law school.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 4:29 AM Author: razzle emerald range
start up doing what?
b-school might be preferable since it makes no pretense to be intellectual. Its highly pragamtic, but if you think the general level of ignorance is bad here...
Date: December 3rd, 2005 4:40 AM Author: bateful aqua jew spot
you know, i've looked at mba program pages, and i have no idea wtf they are supposed to be learning. i guess the case method could be some sort of useful way of thinking about things through examples. i'm thinking an MA in Econ. I could get into a TTT program.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 4:53 AM Author: razzle emerald range
you'll figure it out. MA in econ. just to get quant skills is NOT necessary. go to a decent bschool as their creative applicant or the one with interesting experience. the world is wide, wider than anyone on this board knows. Unfortunately people with lives dont post once they get there.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 4:17 AM Author: lilac idiotic personal credit line idea he suggested
Macedonio Fernández -- but unfortunately, only a few excerpts from his writings have been translated into English. Here's an encyclopedia entry about the guy:
Fernández, Macedonio (1874-1952) Argentinean author and thinker. Fernández was an eccentric, brilliant philosopher who loved poetry and humor. His metaphysical essays, which are so poetic, imaginative, and personal that he referred to them as novels, include: _No toda es vigilia la de los ojos abiertos_ (_It Is Not All Vigil, That of the Open Eyes_, 1928), _Papeles de recienvenido_ (_Papers of a Newcomer_, 1929), and _Una novela que comienza_ (_A Novel That Begins_, 1940). He admired Emerson and Thoreau and corresponded with William James, who was impressed by his Metaphysical Theory of Emotions. As a phenomenologist, he believed that perceptions and emotions are all that can be proven to exist. His "deconstruction" of Descartes is reminiscent of Derrida: he said "I have not found the self within me nor without me," and concluded that, tragically, the closest one can come to the existence of "self" is in the death of what is loved. Never interested in publishing, he was pressed to do so by friends after losing many manuscripts. An intellectual anarchist, playfully disordered, unsystematic, and digressive, among his miscellanea was his definitive work: _Museo de la novela eterna_ (_Museum of the Eternal Novel_, 1967), an unending text composed of several "prologues" describing "the habits of a psyche without a body." His prose is dense and elusive, sometimes mind-twisting to the point of existential absurdity; yet he uses a colloquial, everyday language full of humor and self-parody. Fernández became a reluctant guru to a whole generation of Argentine writers, and his influence extends from Gómez de la Serna to Borges and Cortázar.
(From _Benét's Reader's Encyclopedia_, 4th ed., New York 1996, p. 346)
Date: December 3rd, 2005 4:27 AM Author: dashing doobsian site
As far as practicality (one that I can apply to my life) - Hume. The most entertaining - Nietzsche. The most to make fun of b/c he's so full of shit - Kant. I was a philosophy major, and I used to respect these guys. I went out into the real world and realized how full of shit they all were. Most of the 'great' philosophers were socially ackward and led bitter, unfulfilling lives and their books are just justifications of their shitty lives. The one philosopher I do respect is Camus. His works were at least applicable to normal life.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 8:40 AM Author: vibrant iridescent theatre factory reset button
Aristotle, Nietzsche, Ayn Rand
And you can eat my sack if you make fun of Rand, true, some of her thinking is flawed but she still had some great ideas and a tremendous impact on popular thinking regarding capitalism.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 10:20 AM Author: vibrant iridescent theatre factory reset button
I don't agree with all of her philosophy about art and music. And I don't like how the objectivist movement demonizes libertarianism and anarcho-capitalism.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 12:35 PM Author: Pontificating big bawdyhouse
Can you be more specific about your complaints with her views on art and music? I'm very curious because I only learned to appreciate both after reading her writings.
I'm not going to profess that I am an expert on any of this as it is been a while since I read the Romantic Manifesto and I am not sure I studied it as thoroughly as it deserved. I remember my main problem with it was the fact that I believed that you can enjoy an artist's work even if you do not believe in their philosophy of life. I might see a painting and consider it beautiful even if the artist was a communist. I might enjoy a musician's work if it makes me feel alive, even if he is a nihilist.
Of course, some of my favorite art and music is made by people whom with I do share similar values.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 12:52 PM Author: Pontificating big bawdyhouse
I doubt AR would say that you can't enjoy art/music produced by people who don't share your values. I gotta go for now, but I'll write more on this later.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 8:19 PM Author: Pontificating big bawdyhouse
Alright, you wrote:
"I remember my main problem with it was the fact that I believed that you can enjoy an artist's work even if you do not believe in their philosophy of life."
- I'll admit right off the bat that I haven't yet read the romantic manifesto, so any suggestions I give here will be my attempt at extrapolating from her other writings. I think AR would say that the things that you find attractive in the artist's work are actually in accordance with your philosophy of life - otherwise, you wouldn't find the art attractive. So, when you say;
"I might see a painting and consider it beautiful even if the artist was a communist. I might enjoy a musician's work if it makes me feel alive, even if he is a nihilist."
what happens is that the communist or nihilist has 'borrowed' forms of art representing ideals not consistent with his own philosophy of life (or, at least, has a conflicted POL), but which are consistent with yours. You respond to the aspects of the art that concord with your philosophy. For example, if a musician were to compose nihilistic lyrics to a song, you might appreciate the tune itself or some poetic rendering of the lyrics, but you could not appreciate the meaning or implication of the lyrics themselves - assuming you don't have a nihilistic philosophy of life.
As far as anarcho-capitalism goes, I think the major problem is that it loses sight of the fact that a limited government is necessary. Because man has the option of choosing to deliberately commit evil acts and will continue to have differing points of view from other men, it is important to have some form of government. The question becomes how limited and in what ways. I realize this is general. If you have any more specific problems/questions, that might be an easier way to go.
Date: December 4th, 2005 2:04 AM Author: Drunken Antidepressant Drug
I studied a lot of that growing up. I guess this might not be philosophy, but I find famous young writers produce excellent works during the decades marked with turmoil and change (much of the 20th century). Some of the modern writers I like are lu xun, liang chi chao, and hu shi. Perhaps I remembered hu shi as an important figure because he opposed the PRC and I was for some time brainwashed by the KMT.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 9:59 AM Author: Carnelian trust fund theater
Indeed. Aside from attempting to sound erudite, what was your point? Have you actually read substantial amounts of those philosophers. or are you just repeating some claim that you've heard elsewhere?
Date: December 3rd, 2005 10:13 AM Author: Carnelian trust fund theater
You contend that some of those philosophers are better than others. The OP didn't ask people to list the "greatest" or "best" philosophers. The OP asked people to list their favorites.
You respond to my list by saying, "then again, the OP does ask for your subjective perspective, as askew as that might be"
"Subjective perspective" compared to what, an objective perspective? "Subjective perspective" is redundant. You probably used it in an attempt to sound even more intelligent. "As askew as that [my perspective] might be" takes a strange turn in light of the former clause.
If this is a matter of "subjective perspective" then there is no reason to think that your perspective on my perspective is, or could be, objective. Thus, any such criticism about my perspective being askew is necessarily undermined insofar as its objectivity.
Perhaps you would do better to inquire why I might have listed them as my "favorite" philosophers to see whether there could be a reason for it. Yet, to say that my preference for certain philosophers is askew is, at best, foolish and fucktarded.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 10:26 AM Author: vibrant iridescent theatre factory reset button
Maybe he is just commenting about how different both are, and how contradictory it seems to appreciate both. It is like saying my favorite books are Atlas Shrugged and the Bible.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 10:34 AM Author: vibrant iridescent theatre factory reset button
Well, in my opinion it is a rather skewed perspective. I couldn't say my favorite philosopher was anyone who I didn't agree with. It is impossible to agree with both the messages in the Bible and those in AS. Either you like them for reasons other than their philosophy (writing skill, personal background, whatever) or you really don't know what you think about these things yourself, or you really don't understand philosophy at all and are just trying to sound smart.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 10:41 AM Author: Carnelian trust fund theater
You've omitted a number of possibilities. It's possible to appreciate an argument without agreeing with it. Similarly, not all the works of Aristotle, Plato, and Kant are entirely incompatible with each other (if only because of topics). Frankly, I enjoy reading their works, not necessarily because I agree with them or because they are part of some consistent philosophic argument, but because they are different from each other and thus make for interesting thought experiments when looking at them together.
Do you think that it's impossible to appreciate Kant's Critique of Pure Reason and also to appreciate Aristotle's works on literary criticism?
Date: December 3rd, 2005 10:54 AM Author: vibrant iridescent theatre factory reset button
I don't think it is impossible to appreciate a philosopher for their writing style or appreciate some of their ideas even if you don't agree with most of them. But I would only list philosophers I really agree with as "my favorite" as I know the reason for this question is usually to find out which ideas you agree with. You can tell an awful lot about a person by the thinkers they support.
Date: December 3rd, 2005 12:50 PM Author: Pontificating big bawdyhouse
Huzzah has explained my thoughts very well.
Also, there is not much value in appreciating arguments if they are wrong. Plato's (and Kant's) philosophy is distinct from Aristotle's; while both can be wrong, both cannot be right. So, grouping them together philosophically is untenable. Now, if you meant to group them by your physical attraction to them...
If you reply to this I'll have to let Huzzah pick up the slack again as my woman is dragging me off to see Plato's Harry Potter movie.
Date: December 4th, 2005 12:56 AM Author: ultramarine place of business school cafeteria
This thread sucked. Don't waste your time reading it.
The only interesting suggestions were: Hume (the credited response), Kuhn (where did that come from?), Brentano, Ayn Rand (at least it's an honest favorite), Sartre, and Nietzsche (well, he's fun to read).