It actually was / is IMO whether you like GTA type games or not (I like all of them but I don't think any before 5 could be recommended as fun to play for the first time if you're not nostalgic for them and are used to and/or prefer modern games)
It probably also makes a difference whether you like LA and the surrounding area or not as the backdrop for the story both visually and culturally (I've spent most of my life there and generally like it relative to the other options I realistically have, so that automatically made me enjoy exploring more)
Date: November 21st, 2026 5:11 PM Author: ohnoes (🧐)
I remember loving gta vice city when I played it at 15 or whatever. I can't remember any of the others outside gta iv (which was very Depressing, something V is definitely not relatively speaking) even though I played them all.
180, so I think you'll like 5 because it's very lighthearted and meant to be accessible unlike the more RDR2-esque realism of 6 (Im really enjoying 6 so far, haven't even done any of the main story yet just enjoying the map and the feel of the vehicles and changing weather and animals etc, but it's clearly something that's a lot more focus intensive in general), so 5 is similar to the Vice City or San Andreas thing of being a playful love letter to their favorite movies set in those places and times (a lot of Michael Mann homages in 5 needless to say, urban legends and SoCal culture jokes etc)
Date: November 21st, 2026 5:16 PM Author: ohnoes (🧐)
I really didn't like RDR 2. It was just way too somber for me, and I loved RDR1 where even though it was somewhat tragic you still did shit like forrest gump your way through the mexican revolution.