Date: November 17th, 2026 3:08 PM Author: GroidStomper1488
their competitive advantage was
1) better chip design
2) CUDA, a software library developed over many years for getting the most out of their chips
3) huang's special business relations with asian manufacturers and suppliers, particularly in taiwan
4) huang's special business relations with asian buyers in singapore and malaysia, who were renting to chinese
5) vendor financing of startups and tech companies
#1 is gradually eroding. the big labs and companies are increasingly doing their own chip design.
#2 is rapidly going away. anthropic recently showed how they could erase the years-long headstart that CUDA had by building the same thing in 3 days for cheaper AMD hardware
#3 appears to be fucked. these were not contractual agreements. TSMC can do business with whomever it wants.
#4 is giga fucked. today nvidia just announced "nat sec and export ban" committee under heavy pressure from fedgov. estimates that asian buying is ~20% of nvidia sales
#5 means risk of failure cascades. there is no more bank of jensen to keep AI startups afloat
altogether this means that NVIDIA has probably topped and will never regain its highs seen this year. i won't be surprised to see it return to its pre-AI valuations within the next two years, near $50 per share
Date: November 18th, 2026 1:17 AM Author: json statham
** HEAT checking op's claims **
0 (histrionic / ice COLD 🧊 ) to 10 (bulletproof / scorching HOT 🥵)
"#1 is gradually eroding. the big labs and companies are increasingly doing their own chip design."
1 / 10 🥶
Google, Amazon and Meta have developed their own chips for years.
But all of them are INCREASING their Nvidia purchases every year, while NVIDIA chip separation gets bigger. Anthropic is literally just a software company. Google and Amazon etc actually make things.
None of them can even catch up to AMD or Intel. When will they catch up to displace NVIDIA?
****
"#2 is rapidly going away. anthropic recently showed how they could erase the years-long headstart that CUDA had by building the same thing in 3 days for cheaper AMD hardware"
0 / 10 🧊
"Building the same thing" = FALSE
"cheaper AMD hardware" = true and makes above even more FALSE
Anthropic ported a single ai prompt to an old AMD chip. This is quite a leap to Anthropic (a 100% software company with no IP or chip fabrication experience), replacing CUDA chips.
That’s like porting Windows calculator to Mac OS and claiming you made PCs obsolete.
****
"#3 appears to be fucked. these were not contractual agreements. TSMC can do business with whomever it wants."
0 / 10 🧊
Your central point is correct that TSMC is legally free to serve everyone.
But advanced chip manufacturing isn't an open marketplace where Google, AMD and Nvidia can request equal production.
Capacity is planned years ahead, allocated through long term production commitments, and influenced by engineering and cultural relationships, order volumes and capital investment.
Nvidia and TSMC have collaborated for 3 decades.
In June 2026, TSMC announced that it was integrating Nvidia AI technologies into its manufacturing processes. That's a much different thesis than anyone with a chip design can make TSMC orders or that any capacity exists for several years.
So you are correct that TSMC can do business with whomever it wants. You are delusional if you think they want to do business with anyone over NVIDIA.
****
"#4 is giga fucked. today nvidia just announced "nat sec and export ban" committee under heavy pressure from fedgov. estimates that asian buying is ~20% of nvidia sales"
1 / 10 🥶
This would be logical if Nvidia cannot find another buyer.
But Nvidia is currently selling into a market with inelastic demand. A loss of 1 customer is instantly replaced by 3 competing bidders outside of China for a higher price than msrp. This will occur in spite of Nvidia increasing prices by 10% every other month no matter what any other company does.
****
"#5 means risk of failure cascades. there is no more bank of jensen to keep AI startups afloat"
0 / 10 🧊
Nvidia startup revenue is irrelevant. See above.
A startup going bankrupt doesn’t mean Nvidia loses money from the old sale, the equipment becomes worthless, or the AI industry collapses.
Startup tech investment by itself is a viable proven strategy in the year 2026 even without selling them anything.
For NVIDIA they get 2 sources of return: sales, plus investment gains. In f1-f3 2026 they recorded over over $25 billion in gains from their startup equity.
Anthropic also committed $900 billion in fixed purchases to get investments from Amazon and Google. Now imagine all of Google's startup deals you never heard of financed with even more ludicrous fixed cost terms payable to Google. Is anyone worried about Google's risk of failure cascades? LOL!!!
Date: November 18th, 2026 10:38 AM Author: wangfei
#1/#2 - jensen stated that his long term strategy was software agnostic of silicon - which i think is why he was taken out. that means that NVDA long term strategy as of when he was CEO last week or whatever was moving towards open source. whether NVDA *can* or wants to pivot their 5+ year strategy without jensen now is an open question. but clearly CUDA + NVDA proprietary silicon was not in jensen's long term strategy. whether CUDAs moat is wide enough is looking suspect vs chinese software now.
also they were maintaining dominance and juicing sales by financing startups, have to imagine that's going to slow down dramatically, too, given the 20% reduction in sales to china and just how jensen-driven it all was. a normal CEO isn't going to do that.
edit: just saw #5, not sure if you added it? anyway i agree this stock could have a long way to fall. we haven't even gotten into the legal issues. leadership going forward is going to be VERY conservative and it appears much of their success was due to jensen's freewheeling.
Date: November 17th, 2026 3:38 PM Author: animeboi (.)
AI was the 2020s version of the dot-com bubble, now take a look at the charts of the companies that participated in both (INTC, GLW, CSCO). They all never hit their bubble tops until this bubble. This crash will be just as epic.
Date: November 18th, 2026 12:27 AM Author: AZNgirl ATC halting all Air China Flights forever
yea i hate all these "experts" with hot takes cause of current events and just doing DONE HERE, in general DONE HERE just doesnt happen for anything really. like IRAN isnt DONE HERE, nothing is ever DONE HERE cause of X event
Date: November 18th, 2026 12:51 AM Author: GroidStomper1488
I know its CUDA moat is gone and other chip makers are already as fast or faster, at lower cost. Their market share will decline and their margins will shrink.
There's a lot of speculation and unknowns. Ken Griffin said he's worried in 10 years the GPU industry will be flooded and have very low margins. But he doesn't know any better than anyone else. He could be right, he could be wrong. But the "experts" are just as goofy as the Redditors here. If we all only took them as gospel the stock would be worth zero, right? And they have literally doubled their quarterly profit in a year. So yeah maybe the party is over and it's a terrible long term bet. But right now today it's a solid as fuck venture.
Date: November 18th, 2026 10:58 AM Author: gunneratttt (gunneratttt)
Well that's the thing; no one knows. We're talking about a highly technical company in an extrmely hot and speculative market. Anyone who actually knows NVDAs technological advantages relative to competitors *and* how that translates into it's current and expected valuation is making millione trading on it and selling his analysis to Wall Street. No one with any real expertise goes online to argue with diletantes about it.
I agree it's wildly speculative. And we've seen bullish and bearish reports surface with fancy names on the masthead. I don't know what to believe. Some people say it will crater to a tiny fraction of the market share. My dad who loves China on a personal level thinks that Jensen was right to get them hooked on our chips. I'm a China hawk like Rubio. No one knows. I'm not claiming to know. I don't have any special insight. But neither do the people writing detailed reports. Maybe it sticky, maybe it's not. My gut instinct says that the board of directors have entrusted the company in better hands. To be clear my gut instinct has been wrong now the last 5 times. 6th time is the charm.
Date: November 18th, 2026 11:24 AM Author: gunneratttt (gunneratttt)
You know I have a lot of experience with F500 BODs. I think it's near impossible he was ousted for anything other than fucking a possible spy and a subordinate. He's one of the most successful CEOs of all time and exercised intense managerial control even relative to other CEOs. And he didn't resist at all. Plus he and the board have been silent about it other than Jensen saying he'd return if offered. Either there's more to the story or the BOD overreacted. But I think there's 0% chance anyone wanted him gone before he got caught fucking a possible spy.
The spy stuff/affairs were known long in advance. Trump admin knew about it. Bessent begged Lutnik to act, ban Megaspeed. He wouldn't. Fight erupted between Bessent, Lutnik, and Rubio over this. The story was buried until after the Midterms. Once the news broke the board dropped the hammer. It was decided long in advance. No deliberation.
I take your point that the spy stuff was #1 with a bullet. National security risk. Funneling chips to China via Singapore and Malaysia. The data center that was really run by the Chinese. No question this was the biggest issue.
But since the ouster the NYT is reporting deeper fissures. Some folks were mad about the dotter, a chef by training, chewing out senior execs. The cult of personality and putting up cartoon Jensens everywhere. His kids being referred to as the Royal Family. OK, this stuff doesn't get him axed alone, of course. But if definitely rubbed people the wrong way.
I would also say if there's a third factor it was the circular financing. Jensen was trying to give away as much product as possible to as many people as possible. He was convinced that Nvidia would become ubiquitous and sticky and he just needed to get everyone hooked on his chips. From a business perspective it's a matter of opinion. You could say OK he's got a point, he operates in the red, clears his orbit, and wins forever. On the other hand maybe shareholders don't like this approach and they want to see a focus on revenue. Ultimately, it's the board who decides how to weight this. Jensen made his bed.
So if you're a board member you've got 3 prongs here, the spy risk stuff, the cult of personality bullshit people were sick of, and the whole circular financing method. Sure I will give you the spy stuff was the biggest issue, but the other two did him no favors.
Date: November 18th, 2026 11:53 AM Author: gunneratttt (gunneratttt)
Factor 2 = More of a reason to keep him on.
Factor 3 = Something the board, CFO, and countless others executed. Not some rogue thing.
The reality is that boards are extremely loyal to CEOs, particularly when the company has been so successful and the CEO is the founder. And firing on an emergency basis like this never happens outside of an actual emergency. Particually when the CEO is so integral and has 60 direct reports. If it was for any reason beyond the perceived liability he created they'd have had him stay on to assist with the transition.
This isnt politics where board members can just act on their whims and personal judgment. Every major decision goes through an army of lawyers and advisors.
My sense is that there was a real antipathy there between the board and the CEO. There was an unwavering 'thanks but no thanks' element here. That all may be true but I think they had all weighed this well in advance. They were just waiting for the shoe to drop. The removal was passed hastily with no second guesses. Clearly this was done well in advance of the public hearing the news. Whatever the reasoning, they were at the end of the rope. The purported love for J was long gone.
Date: November 18th, 2026 12:10 PM Author: gunneratttt (gunneratttt)
That's not clear at all to me, in fact I think that theory is impossible. There's a lot of people that interact with corporate boards here and elsewhere, There's a reason why the only people postulating theories like this are people with no experience with them.
It could be propaganda but NYT is definitely painting it this way. The smear campaign is in full swing. The board acted decisively and are unwavering. Anything is possible but the breadcrumbs coming out in the MSM align with what I'm saying fwiw.
Date: November 18th, 2026 12:42 PM Author: gunneratttt (gunneratttt)
Link to any reporting that those factors played into the board's decision? People gossiping about the current thing isn't evidence that board wanted to axe Jensen before this scandal.
Date: November 18th, 2026 11:40 AM Author: GroidStomper1488
I know people building out data centers right now, who are looking at AMD hardware and scratching their heads, saying, “How is this not just a better value than Nvidia in every way? I’m getting more flops per dollar”
Date: November 18th, 2026 12:48 PM Author: LL Cool Bean
Good friend worked for them for years, on the compute side, he quit recently, he'd been saying its all a bubble for years and had been selling his stock immediately whenever he could. Probably cost him millions but he said a crash was coming
Date: November 18th, 2026 12:49 PM Author: AZNgirl ATC halting all Air China Flights forever
really, just got off the tellie with my buddy who's a janitor at NVDA HQ he said revenue is still booming and there's loads of birdshit pussy in jensen's old office they are literally licking his chair and table and stuff just trying to get his sperm off it