Date: October 3rd, 2016 11:48 AM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
Literally fighting the revolutionary war nearly collapsed the UK economy. Just sending over 30k troops was a massive effort. Never before had an army of that size even been sent over to the US. They were counting on loads of loyalists supporting them for provisions and troops once they arrived. The main question Howe, Cornwallis, Bourgoyne, and Clinton had were "where the fuck are they loyalists?"
Clinton wasn't able to launch any major campaigns because he only had like 3 months of supplies and only 60 days of reserves-less than half of what was considered necessary for a campaign- and this was basically the case for 4 years.
Even when Clinton was finally wanting to launch a campaign, when France and Spain joined the war, all his troops were siphoned off to go die of disease in Jamacia and St. Lucia. At one point he sent 5k troops from NYC to St. Lucia and within a year half those troops were dead and the other half never returned. He also had to send troops to West Florida, St. Kitts, St. Augustine, Canada.
By 1778, Clinton only had 13k troops to defend NYC with, which was less than half of what he thought it would take to mount a campaign. During the entirety of the war, UK only sent 4k in reinforcements to North America. The rest went elsewhere in the war.
The only time the Brits actually launched campaigns resulted in entire armies being lost at Saratoga and Yorktown.
Also, pretty much the entire British government prosecuting the war wanted to resign instead of fight it. Lord North tendered his resignation like 15 times during the war, even broke down and started crying in a session of Parliament.
Clinton tendered his resignation an equal number of times, but was denied because it would look bad if the top commanders in North America kept resigning. When they finally gave him permission to resign, he changed his mind. The only people in the British cabinet that were gung ho about the war effort were King George and George Germain.
Tl;dr- UK didn't have enough men and money to keep the US in the revolutionary war without a bunch of loyalist support. There was no such support to be found and therefore there was no way the UK could've kept the US.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 11:53 AM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
Germain proposed this after Yorktown actually. He proposed they just hang on to the parts of the US they had- Charleston, NYC, various other coastal areas, and Canada. The British parliment didn't think this was a viable alternative due to the cost of maintaining garrisons to prohibit combined french/us forces from surrounding them.
By 1780, the French navy was slightly superior to the UK navy in North America. The majority of the UK navy was devoted to the channel to prevent France from invading the UK directly. They just didn't see an alternative.
Germain did wrongly predict that once the US left so would Canada. Lord Carlton who was the governor of Canada for the brits at the time did a good job ensuring the French colonists were happy under British rule and didn't turn to America.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 11:57 AM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
Sort of. I mean if it was just a rabble of confused idiots, it never would've succeeded. If Howe had surrounded Washington after taking NYC, which was possible, they could've won.
Problem is, the UK didn't want to fight the US in the early stages. They kept trying to make peace, which allowed the US army to survive long enough to establish itself. The Howe brothers thought taking NYC and showing British military power, then offering favorable terms to come back to the UK would be sufficient.
Their strategy was so confused that it failed to accomplish its goals. Allowing Washington to escape with the majority of his army lost the war. Probably was the only hope of actually crushing the rebellion. There were a lot of fence riders waiting to see which side would win. Capturing Washington and the US army would've probably caused a mass defection to the UK. With the taking of NYC, one person who signed the declaration of Independence changed his mind and took an oath of loyalty to the UK. Another crushing victory might have resulted in more defections.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 12:22 PM Author: drab associate center
perhaps they realized long term that you wouldn't be able to hold the colonists as slaves if they didn't want to be held that way. they were hoping for a peaceful reconciliation, and when that didn't happen, they jumped ship
Date: October 3rd, 2016 12:00 PM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
They had a serious debt problem and needed someone to pay for it. The average colonial citizen living in America paid much less in taxes than the average brit living in the UK. They tried to just increase the tax load to make it less lower than the UK citizens, but the colonists went nuts anyways.
Most of the Brit politicians talked about the colonists as children spoiled from an over indulgent parent that now needed to be disciplined into submission.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 12:09 PM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
which was odd because various planters in the carribean had seats in parliment. It would've been interesting to see if there would've been a rebellion if they'd given seats to North American colonists in parliment.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 12:14 PM Author: titillating chad
The first time the British got a good lesson in why it's a bad idea to just sail your warships directly at well fortified coastal batteries.
Defense of Charleston during the land siege was disgraceful. Besides for the total lack in interest in raising the numbers to put up a defense, 15 soldiers sharing a musket could have prevented Cornwallis from crossing the Ashley River (of course no attempt was made).
Loss of a major American city, and a major port, without a serious defense mounted.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 12:35 PM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
Especially since Charleston was the wealthiest city captured by the Brits to that date. Even so, Benjamin Lincoln had 1500 troops and gave up too easily.
The taking of Charleston probably kept the North government in power for a couple of extra years.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 8:31 PM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
The British could not have held the territory they took. The burning of Washington was just a raid. The British superiority in naval forces gave it an advantage that it didn't have in revolutionary war. I haven't studied the impact on British economy, but it appears the war did cause Canada to go into a deep recession that some say caused the rebellion of 1837
Still, ANY British commitment should have been able to crush that ragtag group of rebels. Even aside from the rebels' problems of men, $$$, and supplies, there were the personality conflicts and regional disputes that constantly threatened Washington's efforts to coordinate forces. Jealous generals who thought they could do better were constantly sniping at him and calling him a failure. Pretty gay to be like "heh heh the British had no chance because they ONLY brought over 15,000 seasoned troops in the greatest military on earth plus tons of mercenaries"
Date: October 3rd, 2016 12:22 PM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
It wasn't a ragtag group of rebels. The entire British strategy was based on the idea that it was just a ragtag group of rebels and once the army showed up, the silent majority of loyalists would come out of the woodwork to support them and supply them. That didn't happen.
15k troops plus mercenaries with not enough supplies, reinforcements, or local guides trying to subdue a population of 2.5 million spread through the entire east coast is nowhere near enough.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 12:25 PM Author: mind-boggling claret ratface
Still, only something like 2-3% of colonists actually fought in the war, with only like 10% of the population giving a shit about the cause. The key was that the colonial elite cared about the cause.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 12:32 PM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
But there was literally nobody that cared to support the british. Even in 1780 after the Brits had been in control of NYC and the South for a while, they were still relying on supplies coming from the UK instead of loyalists. If you can't even find people to support you when your army is there, you're in deep shit-especially if you were counting on them supporting you for men and materials.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 12:36 PM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
The funny thing is the opposition in Parliament wore US revolutionary war uniform coats to Parliament sessions. Imagine some yankee congressman sitting in Congress wearing a gray jacked of a confederate uniform during the entire civil war. Amazing they tolerated it.
Date: October 3rd, 2016 8:32 PM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
Nah, Lincoln had the us military sit in on Maryland legislatures secession deliberations he was so committed to holding the us together. Even jailed pro southern editors. He prob woulda jailed johnsonn for wearing it
Date: April 19th, 2019 3:44 PM Author: Slap-happy school cafeteria
titcr,
He had an entire brigade surround the legistaltive house for "security purposes" just so pro-south bros understood what was going to happen to them if they voted the "wrong" way".
Date: October 3rd, 2016 8:45 PM Author: Zombie-like national
The Revolution was not a single struggle, but a series of four separate Wars of Independence, waged in very different ways by the major cultures of British America. The first American Revolution (1775-76) was a massive popular insurrection in New England. An army of British regulars was defeated by a Yankee militia which was much like the Puritan train bands from which they were descended. These citizen soldiers were urged into battle by New England’s ‘black regiment’ of Calvinist clergy. The purpose of New England’s War for Independence, as stated both by ministers and by laymen such as John and Samuel Adams, was not to secure the rights of man in any universal sense. Most New Englanders showed little interest in John Locke or Cato’s letters. They sought mainly to defend their accustomed ways against what the town of Malden called ‘the contagion of venality and dissipation’ which was spreading from London to America.
Many years later, historian George Bancroft asked a New England townsman why he and his friends took up arms in the Revolution. Had he been inspired by the ideas of John Locke? The old soldier confessed that he had never heard of Locke. Had he been moved by Thomas Paine’s Common Sense? The honest Yankee admitted that he had never read Tom Paine. Had the Declaration of Independence made a difference? The veteran thought not. When asked to explain why he fought in his own words, he answered simply that New Englanders had always managed their own affairs, and Britain tried to stop them, and so the war began.
In 1775, these Yankee soldiers were angry and determined men, in no mood for halfway measures. Their revolution was not merely a mind game. Most able-bodied males served in the war, and the fighting was cruel and bitter. So powerful was the resistance of this people-in-arms that after 1776 a British army was never again able to remain in force on the New England mainland.
The second American War for Independence (1776-81) was a more protracted conflict in the middle states and the coastal south. This was a gentlemen’s war. On one side was a professional army of regulars and mercenaries commanded by English gentry. On the other side was an increasingly professional American army led by a member of the Virginia gentry. The principles of this second American Revolution were given their Aristotelian statement in the Declaration of Independence by another Virginia gentleman, Thomas Jefferson, who believed that he was fighting for the ancient liberties of his ‘Saxon ancestors.’
The third American Revolution reached its climax in the years from 1779 to 1781. This was a rising of British borderers in the southern backcountry against American loyalists and British regulars who invaded the region. The result was a savage struggle which resembled many earlier conflicts in North Britain, with much family feuding and terrible atrocities committed on both sides. Prisoners were slaughtered, homes were burned, women were raped and even small children were put to the sword.
The fourth American Revolution continued in the years from 1781 to 1783. This was a non-violent economic and diplomatic struggle, in which the elites of the Delaware Valley played a leading part. The economic war was organized by Robert Morris of Philadelphia. The genius of American diplomacy was Benjamin Franklin. The Delaware culture contributed comparatively little to the fighting, but much to other forms of struggle.
The loyalists who opposed the revolution tended to be groups who were not part of the four leading cultures. They included the new imperial elites who had begun to multiply rapidly in many colonial capitals, and also various ethnic groups who lived on the margins of the major cultures: notably the polyglot population of lower New York, the Highland Scots of Carolina and African slaves who inclined against their Whiggish masters.
Date: March 29th, 2017 10:19 AM Author: chartreuse bespoke pit
(1) thanks, as always, for the great content
(2) so it was just like an order of magnitude more expensive (like 10X) to send troops to America then to deploy them on the continent? Less than half a century later they deployed like 250K or so total to fight napoleon right? Seems like if they really cared they could've sent 50K to crush the American rebels.
Date: March 29th, 2017 11:17 AM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
I don't know that they could've sent 50k troops over and properly provisioned them. Sending 30k was the largest army that had ever been sent to that point and they had an immensely difficulty time provisioning that army due to lack of loyalist support.
Plus, anywhere they marched, they'd "crush" the rebels, then, as they continued to march, the rebels would move back into the area they just left. If they stationed men in every town they took, the forces would all be too small to fight a rebel army that could form instantly, attack a (now) small British force, and then disappear again. Also, the logistics of provisioning british army all over the continent was probably more than an army could handle in the 1700s.
With that said, that's an interesting point about the Napoleanic wars. The brits did have troops stationed all over the empire, but I think most of the troops were stationed in Europe, which may have been easier to gather provisions from. Plus, they had allies that could also help with provisions.
Date: March 29th, 2017 11:22 AM Author: Underhanded fuchsia theatre roommate
Thread seems a little misleading. If France and Spain were critical factors, it seems more accurate to argue that the British couldntwin the war after Saratoga. That's a good two+ years into the war.
I do broadly agree that the war was never that close to being lost anytime after 1776.
Date: April 18th, 2019 10:52 AM Author: adventurous outnumbered dopamine
They were critical factors even if they didn’t enter the war though. British being mired down in the colonies created opportunities for French to attack the British colonies in the Caribbean, even if not directly on behalf of an ally. Even if the Brits has been able to concentrate all of its power in the colonies, that power, at its peak, 30k soldiers who they could barely provision due to lack of loyalist support.