Date: March 8th, 2006 5:06 PM Author: appetizing piazza
No I'm serious. What is irrational about Iran? There's certainly nothing irrational about wanting nukes. It's a society with deep roots and a high level of development. I need examples explaining why they are irrational.
Just because you say something is irrational doesn't make it so.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:33 PM Author: Bronze whorehouse
I didn't say something is irrational. I will say that someone is being irrational. If you need a hint as to his identity, he's about to make an idiotic reply to this post.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:06 PM Author: Diverse Trust Fund
Busher is a a front. Its a type of reactor that has zero use in a bomb making project. The Iranians use the reactor to argue that all they want is a civil program. Nobody is fooled and the Russian are just making money. Bushehr was actually a German reactor originally, the Russkies are just finishing it.
Date: March 8th, 2006 4:55 PM Author: maniacal dysfunction school cafeteria
I don't think it's a question of their "right." We could argue for a nation's sovereignty and self-determination as justification for allowing their nuclear weapons until that nation uses them or sells them to rogue terrorist groups that use them. But even so, one could argue that Iran's human rights record makes them significantly more suspect and less trustworthy with those weapons. The world functions as much more of a Darwinian struggle than most people would like to admit, so I could care less about sovereignty as justification for allowing them nukes.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:00 PM Author: maniacal dysfunction school cafeteria
I think that's a bit of an exaggeration, we operated under the same realist assumptions throughout the Cold War. It's not as if we somehow gained those values once the Berlin Wall fell and we found ourselves as the lone hegemon in international affairs.
I'm not trying to throw this completely off-track, but could you give your thoughts on the current prisoner abuse/detainment situation? (I'm not going to turn it into a big debate or argument since I have to get back to work...I'd just be curious what your thoughts are since your goal is human rights.)
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:09 PM Author: appetizing piazza
Those "realist" assumptions are what are allowing us to torture people and detain people indefinitely.
It is also the same realist assumptions that allowed Hitler to turn Germany into a totalitarian dictatorship from a western liberal democracy. It was essentially a state of emergency in response to "real" threats for the whole run of the third reich.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:19 PM Author: maniacal dysfunction school cafeteria
Realism had a second go during the Cold War, various attempts to sway it from its course by fools like Jimmy Carter notwithstanding. I'd say realism redeemed itself adequately. Torture and detaining prisoners are ancillary questions on which there is nothing approaching a unified "realist" position.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:22 PM Author: appetizing piazza
yuo lost me. I was using his term "real" as constituting those moments where the United States throws human rights out the window in order to protect itself liek it is currently doing with torture, illegal wars, indefinite detention of people, and secret prisons.
Since when does the "sovereignty" of an irrational outlaw nation comprise "all the values" of liberal western democracy, or, for that matter, somehow justify bloodthirsty holocaust-denying terrorist nations developing weapons of mass destruction?
Date: March 8th, 2006 4:58 PM Author: Dull depressive
"Sovereignty" is a TTT justification for a country doing whatever the hell it wants. As PD admitted, the world nature is pretty Darwinian, whether we like it to or not, and a lot of what "should" be allowed is based on subjective interpretations of what country is ultimately good and what country is ultimately bad.
I love how you assumed I was saying it was a bad thing and that we shouldn't get to determine things. (I was, but it seems like an interesting assumption.)
I'm personally a fan of the UN route. I'd rather have a couple of people agree than have it be solely US-determined. I'd rather have the solution go that route also. I know I'll get attacked for saying that, however, and I'm not sure I'm knowledgeable enough to be able to counter all the possible reactions, so just consider it food for thought.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:14 PM Author: impertinent costumed forum
Because they didn't sign some treaty something or other. And nevermind that Israel didn't sign that treaty either, because they're our Jewish friends and we like them.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:09 PM Author: Narrow-minded fortuitous meteor station
because Israel would be gone within 2 weeks after Iran became nuclear-capable, and the middle east would soonafter become a nuclear wasteland. And all that oil would be gone, and the rest of the world would go down the tubes as a result.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:16 PM Author: Narrow-minded fortuitous meteor station
current leadership of Iran seems to think otherwise, in regards to Israel. That Muhasdfasdfasdfjim dood has repeatedly talked about the destruction of Israel, denial of the Holocaust, etc, and believes that some prophet will return when some catastrpohic thing happens, or something.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:15 PM Author: Dun Chest-beating Faggotry Crackhouse
israel would defeat iran in less than 2 weeks. them jews are some tough sumbitches. they neutralized the entire egyptian air force overnight in '67 and they've had nukes much longer than iran will have. and they'd really have nothing to lose with a pre-emptive strike. i actually kind of want to see it happen.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:23 PM Author: Dun Chest-beating Faggotry Crackhouse
yeah they're a 4th quarter team. nowadays, though, the only way they'll ever be extinguished is after their last nuke detonates [read: tehran would be a glass parking lot, as would palestine, syria, and probably mecca.]
strong states determine morality and impose its values on others. If America wasn't the only superpower, you wouldn't even talking about states' rights, sovereignty, or any of that bullshit. It really just comes down to power and nukes. That's the current system we're in. It's only after a states' borders are secure does talk of morality spring up. Since Iran having nukes would not make us secure, this threat must be eliminated before we give a shit about morality. If Iran had nukes that threatened us, America would do everything in its power to remove the threat morality be damned, even if it meant sodomizing every Iranian.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:25 PM Author: appetizing piazza
I only use the language of western liberal democracies to describe the situation in order to hint at how hypocritical our nation is. Using our own ideals, there is nothing that should bar Iran from having nukes.
What you get from the rabble on this board and the politicians is other bullshit excuses that don't make any sense according to their own logic.
This is what I mean when I say we throw our values out the window when we actually feel threatened. And by we I mean the ruling elites of America.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:29 PM Author: maniacal dysfunction school cafeteria
It ultimately comes down to the premise you've imposed that the rules by which a liberal western democracy abides should apply to non-liberal, repressive tyrannical regimes. It's a flimsy connection based on a set of moral equivalencies (like how we repress our population in different ways, how we have a leader that seems delusional, we have a bunch of factors that reduce us to the same level of legitimacy on the world stage as Iran) that possess little merit. When this case gets referred to the security council which determines that military action against Iran is justified to prevent them from attaining nukes, will you oppose this decision?
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:33 PM Author: appetizing piazza
It's not based on any moral equivalencies. It's based on the fact that the power of the executive brnach of the government is now able to expand unchecked to a degree that it can, on its own, decide whom to torture, whom to kill, whom to detain indefinitely, whom to spy on, etc. This is a serious negation of the values we say we fight for.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:29 PM Author: Dun Chest-beating Faggotry Crackhouse
nice try. you made it clear in your first post your far-left political views, which you were looking to argue for. and you did. learn the definition of a flame.
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:30 PM Author: disrespectful menage jew
If that's the goal, it was a pretty poor job. He should have chosen a country not ran by psychos who continually threaten to extinguish an entire population. Its a big stretch to say it applies to all "countr[ies] that [aren't] controlled by George W."
Date: March 8th, 2006 5:34 PM Author: Beady-eyed Electric Furnace
The problem with Iran is that it's run by incompetent anti-intellectual plutocrats who exploit religious fundamentalism to retain power, and that they are afriad of losing prominence within their sphere of influence so they resort to violence to achieve their goals.