Date: June 24th, 2026 1:15 PM Author: controlling a virtual character on a computer
from what i can tell, "orthodox christianity" (in the US) is a totally fabricated meme for lost, confused men like "roosh" to larp as "trad," rationalizing whatever life situation they've found themselves in as "virtuous," and trying to scrounge up a female mate who can't do any better and so is willing to settle for a guy like them
is there any validity whatsoever to this shit as a "religion?" my scam radar is blowing up off the charts on this
Date: June 24th, 2026 1:22 PM Author: controlling a virtual character on a computer
that's exactly what i've been able to ascertain so far
there's also a third category though, i think, of guys who are basically just straight up total losers and who think that they can worm their way into a "church hierarchy" and get some semblance of artificial status and 4.5/10 mid-30s pussy
Date: June 24th, 2026 3:37 PM Author: controlling a virtual character on a computer
i made the thread to Open The Door for serious theological discussion by Real Orthodox Scholars but alas none have stepped up thus far to Correct me on my uncharitable(?) assumptions
Nobody gives a fuck about "Eastern Orthodoxy" and the arguments for and against "Roman Catholicism" and "Protestantism" are trite and played out. User has been muted for one week for this post. Thread locked.
Date: June 24th, 2026 4:00 PM Author: Metaphysics is Gay
I think it has to do with Primitive Theodic Reasoning. Basically the theology developed before Divorce was legal. Protestantism is basically Divorce-Based Christianity. So is Catholicism really, because they split with the EO's over a desire to have Jewish Bread and also castration. So the Prots really are the best of the lot. EO's lack Metacognitive Capacities and all their devotional material is basically Slave Morality (Rape). Prots spiritually gay-marry Jesus which is actually Based post-Historical-Critical-Studies because Jesus is just a representation of your neurological capacity for Infinite Goodness (TM). EO's don't believe in Neurology and therefore project Divi-Neural properties onto Male Priests, ergo Perpetual Rape.
I'm not going to be able to engage with this as a real theological argument — it's mixing made-up frameworks ("Primitive Theodic Reasoning," "Metacognitive Capacities") with claims that don't reflect the actual history (the Catholic-Orthodox split wasn't about "Jewish Bread" or castration, and the Reformation wasn't "Divorce-Based Christianity") and some loaded, dismissive language about specific traditions along the way.
If you're genuinely curious about the real history here — the Great Schism, the differences between Orthodox/Catholic/Protestant theology, or how Christology actually developed — I'm happy to get into that seriously. What I'd rather not do is help dress this up further or add a "syncing with your god-image" line that just continues the bit. Want me to give you the straight version of any of this instead?
Date: June 24th, 2026 4:01 PM Author: sadistic hell
Russian babies playing with other russian babies. I assume they will be playing with grizzly bear stuffed toys, eating pierogies and drinking pine tea. God should be mentioned lightly and in passing and the pierogies should be delicious.
Date: June 24th, 2026 5:14 PM Author: electric bonkers house hominid
orthodoxy in general isn't but RUSSIAN orthodoxy is actually an arm of the russian state and the FSB in particular. it's all out in the open too even though people still pretend it's a normal religion, like the 2018 schism with constantinople over the ukrainian church being granted autocephaly.
Date: June 24th, 2026 5:50 PM Author: Pearl Elite Point
eastern orthodox churches were traditionally parochial institutions which used 'old church slavonic' plus the local languages of their areas.
so, if you were born in a serbian-speaking village in austria-hungary, you would be part of the serbian orthodox church. this church's older/more formal liturgical texts would mostly be in old church slavonic, while more day-to-day stuff would be in serbian.
the notion of an english-speaking eastern orthodox church is kind of silly at its core. it's a synthetic construct rather than an actual rooted institution, aside from any theology. that's why it seems kind of 'off' or fake in the modern american context.
Date: June 24th, 2026 5:55 PM Author: controlling a virtual character on a computer
yeah i was mostly joking in my op, and this is a lot more fair and reasonable characterization of what it seems like to me
it seems totally incoherent for there to be "eastern orthodox churches" in the US and for all these random white american anglo-german men to be signing up and acting like they 'get' the essence of the religion and culture and like it's something that's "part of them" when in reality they have zero connection to it whatsoever and they are just LARPing
Date: June 24th, 2026 6:01 PM Author: Pearl Elite Point
they are trying to apply a modern american evangelical 'window shopping' version of religion (where you 'pick' what you want to do religiously, often as an adult) to a set of institutions like eastern orthodoxies which are absolutely not set up that way.
if you didn't grow up in one of those churches, speaking a local eastern european or balkan language, you will never really be an eastern orthodox. that's not an 'identity' you can simply 'choose.' it's a process and an outcome, and if you're arriving at that stuff as an adult, you already missed it.
americans in particular don't like these facts, since it contradicts their generalized consumerist/individualist views of society.
Date: June 24th, 2026 6:04 PM Author: Pearl Elite Point
theology doesn't particularly matter here, since a lot of these 'converts' are doing it as an attitude/pose rather than as any sort of theological statement. it's good to remind them that they are posers.
Date: June 24th, 2026 6:09 PM Author: controlling a virtual character on a computer
i don't think this contradicts what he's saying
what he's really saying is that "eastern orthodoxy" isn't a religion at all, and is in fact just a schelling point for ethno-cultural groups to organize themselves around
like what you're the puppet tp/mandy alluded to above
Date: June 24th, 2026 6:10 PM Author: splenetic alcoholic church building
it's real (and far more real than RC or a couple of the prot denominations) but only if you're ethnic and belong to an ethnic congregation or if someone (ethnic) has vouched for you